Rating System

How do we keep tabs on our bourbon?

Price: How much did this bourbon cost? Most of our Bourbons are purchased at a Virginia ABC store.

Type: Bourbon is at least 51% corn.  We may add pages to discuss other whiskeys like those that are Rye or Wheat based, etc…

Smell/Nose: We went simple on this: Pleasant, Neutral or Unpleasant.

Alcohol Burn: This is the “fire” that the drinker experiences. Whether you feel this in your gut or your mouth, you know what it feels like. This rating is based on a scale of A, B, C, D or E where A is burn-free and E is fire water!

Taste: As we have tried different Bourbons we found that they are either spicy, leathery, earthy, or they are sweet, caramel flavored and vanilla flavored. Most Bourbons fall on a scale between these 2 distinct flavor categories. We have designed a scale from -10 to +10 where -10 represents a very earthy, leathery, spicy flavor, and +10 is a caramel, vanilla candy sweet. So a bourbon that is a “0″ would be both sweet and spicy and earthy, but not particularly more of one or the other. Whereas a bourbon with a “7″ score would be very sweet and have little earth or spice.

Overall: This is our overall score ranging from 0 to 100 based on our overall rating of the drink. Since we both favor sweet Bourbons (+3 to +7 on the taste scale) we attempt to be objective with this rating. This is a rating of nose, start, burn, finish, depth and overall character of the whiskey. Please keep in mind that this score can be re-adjusted as we grade more drinks and review old scores. As we start tasting “better” Bourbons, the weaker ones will be pushed farther down the scale.

Comments: This is the section where we point out the strengths and weaknesses – like value for money, enjoyment level, need for more ice or water or simply neat, is this mixer only….ideas we thought to share.

 

41 thoughts on “Rating System

  1. Pingback: Buffalo Trace | The Bourbon Guide

  2. Pingback: Rowan’s Creek | The Bourbon Guide

  3. Pingback: Willetts Pot Still Reserve | The Bourbon Guide

  4. Pingback: Maker’s Mark | The Bourbon Guide

  5. Pingback: Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey | The Bourbon Guide

  6. Pingback: Filibuster | The Bourbon Guide

  7. Pingback: Black Maple Hill | The Bourbon Guide

  8. Pingback: Bowman Brothers | The Bourbon Guide

  9. Pingback: Larceny | The Bourbon Guide

  10. Pingback: Smooth Ambler | The Bourbon Guide

  11. Pingback: Angel’s Envy | The Bourbon Guide

  12. Pingback: Evans Williams 1783 | The Bourbon Guide

  13. Pingback: Lexington | The Bourbon Guide

  14. Pingback: Hirsch 20 Year | The Bourbon Guide

  15. Pingback: Belle Meade | The Bourbon Guide

  16. Pingback: Old Forester 2012 Birthday | The Bourbon Guide

  17. Pingback: Rock Hill Farms | The Bourbon Guide

  18. Pingback: Colonel E. H. Taylor – Single Barrel | The Bourbon Guide

  19. Pingback: Weller Special Reserve | The Bourbon Guide

  20. Pingback: Rebel Reserve | The Bourbon Guide

  21. Pingback: Booker's | The Bourbon Guide

  22. Pingback: Weller Special Reserve | The Bourbon Guide

  23. Pingback: Rebel Reserve | The Bourbon Guide

  24. Pingback: Woodford Reserve | The Bourbon Guide

  25. Pingback: Four Roses Single Barrel | The Bourbon Guide

  26. Pingback: Rock Hill Farms | The Bourbon Guide

  27. Pingback: Colonel E. H. Taylor - Small Batch | The Bourbon Guide

  28. Pingback: Blanton's | The Bourbon Guide

  29. Pingback: Bulleit Bourbon - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  30. Pingback: Breckenridge Bourbon - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  31. Pingback: Sam Houston - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  32. Pingback: John B. Stetson - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  33. Pingback: Berkshire Bourbon | The Bourbon Guide

  34. Pingback: Leopold Bros - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  35. Pingback: Ancient Ancient Age | The Bourbon Guide

  36. Pingback: Hancock's President's Reserve - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  37. Pingback: Jefferson's Presidential Select 18 yr. - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  38. Pingback: Elmer T. Lee - The Bourbon Guide | The Bourbon Guide

  39. Pingback: Cleveland - The Bourbon Guide - The Bourbon Guide

  40. Pingback: Rhetoric - The Bourbon Guide

  41. Pingback: J. R. Ewing - The Bourbon Guide

Leave a Reply