Here are our Special Occasion Bourbons. Please note this is still under construction (for example, this list is in no particular order)
The following are not ‘special’ occasion, but Bourbons that you should have in your cabinet.
This section of the bourbon tasting guide is permanently under construction. We intend to add links to each post as well as the relevant data for easier searching. You know when you are standing in the ABC store and don’t know what to buy. The table can be sorted by each header so feel free to look
| id | Score | idBottle | Bottle | BottleDescription | Proof | idReviewer | Reviewer | idNose | Nose | idBurn | idLeather | LeatherDesc | idSweet | SweetDesc | Date | Comments | Served | PostURL | PictureURL | Brand | BrandDescription | Distillery | DistilleryLocation | DistilleryDescription |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| id | Score | idBottle | Bottle | BottleDescription | Proof | idReviewer | Reviewer | idNose | Nose | idBurn | idLeather | LeatherDesc | idSweet | SweetDesc | Date | Comments | Served | PostURL | PictureURL | Brand | BrandDescription | Distillery | DistilleryLocation | DistilleryDescription |
| 363 | 92 | 17 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Small Batch | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.07.18 | Any house will enjoy this – a smooth 100 proof beverage; slightly sweet but with a weight to the liquid that holds many flavors while remaining smooth. | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsmallbatch/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSmallBatch.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 369 | 77 | 8 | Blanton's Bottle 104 | Each bottle has a distinctive cork with a letter imbedded into the picture of the horse. The idea is to collect all of the letters. This bottle was the letter L – We have are not even close to collecting of the corks to spell B L A N T O N S. Honestly, we are big fan's of cool bottles and gimmicks, but this is just a little too much. Bourbon was dumped on 2011.08.15 from barrel no 23 stored in warehouse 11 on rick # 2 – giving us bottle #104. | 93 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.06.13 | My first drink of the day – and the first sip was full of burn and pepper between my lips and gums. Second try gave me confidence that this is a full bourbon and one that will put hair on your chest. The burn alone brought down my score. Not one I would naturally go for but a great option when hosting guests. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/blantons/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Blantons.jpg | Blanton's Single Barrel | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 371 | 75 | 3 | Belle Meade Bourbon | A friend of mine was in Tennessee and was at a liquor store reading labels to me to see if I needed anything for my collection. Over the phone he read the name of this bourbon and then added…”it has a classy bottle”…. and I was sold. I am a sucker for a nice bottle. Call me superficial, I know the liquor will be drunk! oh and... It is a high-rye straight bourbon; double gold medal winner at the 2015 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.06.12 | Burn – is my first thought. As for my second thought, shudder – this is not my favorite. I did eat a chocolate cookie before this tasting – but I digress… | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/belle-meade/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/BelleMeade.jpg | Belle Meade | Nelson's Green Brier Distillery | Nashville, TN | ||
| 372 | 90 | 3 | Belle Meade Bourbon | A friend of mine was in Tennessee and was at a liquor store reading labels to me to see if I needed anything for my collection. Over the phone he read the name of this bourbon and then added…”it has a classy bottle”…. and I was sold. I am a sucker for a nice bottle. Call me superficial, I know the liquor will be drunk! oh and... It is a high-rye straight bourbon; double gold medal winner at the 2015 San Francisco World Spirits Competition. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2013.06.12 | Very Nice – too bad it has a little burn otherwise a great bourbon. A very nice drink, with sweet and smooth flavors. Buy it! | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/belle-meade/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/BelleMeade.jpg | Belle Meade | Nelson's Green Brier Distillery | Nashville, TN | ||
| 373 | 78 | 69 | Hirsch 20 Year Special Reserve | A rare bottle only 120 casks were produced from Feb 27, 1987 mash in Illinois. | 96 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.06.12 | The rating is on my taste scale, but for those that desire wood, spice and pepper with a little licorice this is for you! A special bourbon many will desire to try yet own. Don't get me wrong it is a nice bottle. However, I leave it for others – for me to drink this cheats others who would truly appreciate it. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/12/hirsch-20-year/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Hirsch20Yr.jpg | Hirsch | Hotaling and Co | Lawrenceburg, IN | ||
| 374 | 75 | 69 | Hirsch 20 Year Special Reserve | A rare bottle only 120 casks were produced from Feb 27, 1987 mash in Illinois. | 96 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -7.00 | Strong (-7) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.06.12 | no sweetness at all. very woody, spicy, leathery with a very earthy after taste. not a smooth easy drink. not my type of flavor but a must have for spice lovers. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/12/hirsch-20-year/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Hirsch20Yr.jpg | Hirsch | Hotaling and Co | Lawrenceburg, IN | ||
| 375 | 88 | 41 | Lexington | Classic looking classy bottle. No bells and whistles, just solid Kentucky bourbon. | 86 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2013.06.12 | Great with ice. A refreshing smooth bargain. Slight body at the end – a very drinkable drink. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/12/lexington/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Lexington.jpg | Lexington | Western Spirits Beverage Company | Bowling Green, KY | ||
| 376 | 86 | 41 | Lexington | Classic looking classy bottle. No bells and whistles, just solid Kentucky bourbon. | 86 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2013.06.12 | Sweet then spice. Very refreshing and nice. very good for the price. I would certainly buy this again and add is it a go to bourbon for me. A must have. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/12/lexington/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Lexington.jpg | Lexington | Western Spirits Beverage Company | Bowling Green, KY | ||
| 378 | 87 | 56 | Smooth Ambler Old Scout 6 year | 6 yrs. old 49.5% (101 proof) Batch 8; Bottle Date June 19, 2012; Bottled by JH; West Virginia. This was a brave choice considering the 101 proof of this whiskey. A proper bourbon guide review would best have been done with a splash of water. Brave… that is how we can describe our drinking! | 101 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.04.28 | Caramel, spice, citrus. Very balanced and incredibly smooth. Really nice drink. One of my favorites. Great all around bourbon. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/04/28/smooth-ambler/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmberOldScout-1.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 390 | 91 | 6 | Black Maple Hill (2013 Original Red Label Wax Top) | Limited Edition – aged in White Oak Casks and Hand Bottled. Red label. | 95 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2013.04.25 | All mine – get your grubby paws off! Very sweet, very smooth with a back of the throat burn. A top notch bourbon that just tastes elite. It was worth the wait – if you see it buy it (for me). | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/black-maple-hill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Black-maple-hill-rotated.jpeg | Black Maple Hill | wheated Stizel-Weller but later thought to be sourced from Kentucky Bourbon Distillers | CVI Brands | San Carlos, CA | a non-distiller spirits importer and bottler based |
| 398 | 95 | 25 | Evan Williams 1783 | This bourbon is a steal! It almost made us pass it on as a bottom shelf no name drink, but that would have been a major mistake. This is a real whiskey and should certainly be included in everyone’s collection. Do not let the cheap price tag fool you. My only comment is: why is Makers so much more… and forget some of the other drinks! | 86 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/evans-williams-1783/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EvanWilliams1783.jpg | Evan Williams | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 402 | 77 | 27 | Filibuster Dual cask | 2 distinct oak barrels. Finished in French Oak barrels. The bottle tested was Batch 1, Bottle 3955 and was purchased in Washington DC. This is a 45% alcohol bourbon. This is a novelty type bourbon, and got some great reviews on-line and in magazines. We are lucky to have a bottle, but now that we tried it…we are stuck with a bottle. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.03.02 | Sweet with wood, lots of wood. Like a sugary piece of oak in your mouth. There is the earthy finish that makes it only a +1 sweetness, but the wood is overwhelming. A very different flavor, but a flavor I would never reach for. My bottle is used just for tastings and for comparison. You really need to like the oak flavor to every buy this bottle. More of a novelty than a legitimate drink. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/02/filibuster/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Filibuster.jpg | Filibuster | MGP of Indiana | Lawrenceburg, IN | Midwest Grain Products of Indiana; owned by Pernod Ricar | |
| 409 | 82 | 9 | Booker's 7 year Straight Bourbon Whiskey | Jim Beam makes this bourbon which is made straight from the barrel and is totally uncut – if you couldn’t tell at 127 proof. Holy cow! Use this to start fires if you are desperate…. might be a great camping bourbon for that reason. A little goes a long way. Sometimes bourbon tasting requires adding branch water to bring out the bourbon’s natural flavors especially at such a high alcohol content. Batch number C03-I-16 | 127 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2013.11.22 | I like the smell and the tingle produced by its aftertaste but I must be honest and admit that I don't like required to add water. As I taste and rate this bourbon, I am being constantly reminded that drinking and updating a website don't go hand in hand. Drink Booker's to drink bourbon not while you must concentrate. | on rocks with a generous splash of water. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bookers/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Bookers.jpg | Bookers | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 410 | 85 | 9 | Booker's 7 year Straight Bourbon Whiskey | Jim Beam makes this bourbon which is made straight from the barrel and is totally uncut – if you couldn’t tell at 127 proof. Holy cow! Use this to start fires if you are desperate…. might be a great camping bourbon for that reason. A little goes a long way. Sometimes bourbon tasting requires adding branch water to bring out the bourbon’s natural flavors especially at such a high alcohol content. Batch number C03-I-16 | 127 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.11.22 | A little Virginia branch water can turn jet fuel into a drinkable delicious bourbon. If you add enough water the burn is diluted and the sweet flavor is able to shine. Because of the dilution one bottle of Booker's might last you a lifetime. | on rocks with a generous splash of water. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bookers/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Bookers.jpg | Bookers | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 413 | 83 | 18 | Elijah Craig 12yr | A small batch Kentucky straight bourbon made from limestone filtered water and a special yeast recipe. In their own words “one of the world’s greatest bourbons”. Please read on to see our perspective. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.12.11 | A high proof drink with flavors of pepper, clove and earth but no sweet. This is very smooth and drinkable but not my taste preference. I would recommend this highly to our fans who like the negative side of our taste scale… this will be a mixer for me. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-12yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ElijahCraig12.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 417 | 89 | 11 | Breckenridge | The “World’s Highest Distillery”. This is a 4x winner of Best American Blended (2016, 17, 18, and 2019) from the World Whiskies Awards and Bourbon of the Year in 2011 at the International Wine & Spirits Competition. | 86 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.01.13 | I first saw this in Colorado but unfortunately not at the distillery. I am now just rating this bottle after it has sat in my bar for over a year. Shame on me – so what about the taste… I noticed citrus and caramel within this savory drink. A nice sipping bourbon to close the evening down. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/breckenridge/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Breckenridge.jpg | Breckenridge | Breckenridge Distillery | Breckenridge, CO | This is made by the self proclaimed “World’s Highest Distillery” at 9,600 feet using snow melt from the Rocky Mountains. | |
| 419 | 88 | 54 | Sam Houston | American straight whiskey made with Kentucky Bourbon and aged in charred white oak barrels; per the distillery’s website. Sam Houston, born a Virginian, was known for bringing Texas into the United States – he is obviously the namesake of Houston. | 86 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2014.01.16 | I have always been a person who will choose a dessert over an appetizer; so I like this. It is sweet and leaves an after taste that lingers for a few moments. It is like eating an alcoholic Sugar Daddy. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/sam-houston/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SamHouston.jpg | Sam Houston | Western Spirits Beverage Company | Bowling Green, KY | ||
| 420 | 90 | 54 | Sam Houston | American straight whiskey made with Kentucky Bourbon and aged in charred white oak barrels; per the distillery’s website. Sam Houston, born a Virginian, was known for bringing Texas into the United States – he is obviously the namesake of Houston. | 86 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2014.01.16 | This is like biting into a caramel candy filled with a tiny amount of whisky. To say this whiskey is sweet would be an understatement, it is saccharine sweet to the point of losing some of its complexity. There is still a hint of flavor, but it is drowned out by sugary vanilla and caramel…. drink this as an after dinner cordial. Is this a bourbon? | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/sam-houston/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SamHouston.jpg | Sam Houston | Western Spirits Beverage Company | Bowling Green, KY | ||
| 425 | 94 | 57 | Van Winkle 12 yr. | 12 year old Van Winkle's special reserve is a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey and this one was from Lot “B”. Van Winkle is a well-known name among the bourbon community which makes their product hard to get. All of their Bourbons are “wheated” or made from corn, wheat and barley which according to them gives a smooth taste and we agree. They now produce their bourbon at the Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, KY. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2014.05.14 | Not my bottle but don't you worry I have one at home too. So the two of us are set. This is my top top top shelf house bourbon. Trouble is you start to drink it and want more – but then look at the bottle and think I better not keep drinking as tomorrow is another day and it too may call for some time with Van Winkle. So smooth and full-bodied to the point that there are many flavors noted. In short I am a fan of wheated Bourbons, and this man makes a good one. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/van-winkle-12-yr | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VanWinkle12yr.jpg | Van Winkle | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 426 | 95 | 57 | Van Winkle 12 yr. | 12 year old Van Winkle's special reserve is a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey and this one was from Lot “B”. Van Winkle is a well-known name among the bourbon community which makes their product hard to get. All of their Bourbons are “wheated” or made from corn, wheat and barley which according to them gives a smooth taste and we agree. They now produce their bourbon at the Buffalo Trace Distillery in Frankfort, KY. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2014.05.14 | Deliciously light and fresh while still have deep rich flavors. Caramel, oak, wheat and fruit are finished by a rush of fire. The man, the myth and the legend do not disappoint. It took me 1 year to get it but it is worth it. Be nice to me and you might get a sip or not. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/van-winkle-12-yr | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VanWinkle12yr.jpg | Van Winkle | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 428 | 83 | 1 | Ancient Ancient Age 10 Yr | This 6 year old Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey could be called triple A or AAA but that has other connotations. It is the fancier version of Ancient Age. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2014.05.21 | Heavy. Sweet taste that quickly turns very spicy. This bourbon is a mouthful and thus not an easy sipper. Not a fantastic drink – but super cheap. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/ancient-ancient-age/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/AncientAncientAge.jpg | Ancient Age | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 435 | 89 | 15 | Cleveland | Batch 006 and is a limited production where they finish with an oxygen enrich accelerated process. This sounds fancy so keep reading to see if we liked it! First though let us explain this process a little more. They start with barrel-aged bourbon but instead of letting it age the old-fashioned way, in a warehouse, they use pressure changes and oxygen to control the aging process. This bottle was pressure aged for 6 months using charred white oak segments and a little science to deliver their product faster (www.clevelandwhiskey.com). | 100 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.02.06 | Friends this is a new age production so if you buy into this then do buy their product. If you prefer bourbon to be aged using only time then this may surprise you. It flavor matches its strength in alcohol. A nice viscosity that is full on the palate. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/cleveland/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Cleveland.jpg | Cleveland Whiskey | Cleveland Whiskey | Cleveland, OH | maker of whiskey by massively accelerating the maturiation process | |
| 436 | 89 | 15 | Cleveland | Batch 006 and is a limited production where they finish with an oxygen enrich accelerated process. This sounds fancy so keep reading to see if we liked it! First though let us explain this process a little more. They start with barrel-aged bourbon but instead of letting it age the old-fashioned way, in a warehouse, they use pressure changes and oxygen to control the aging process. This bottle was pressure aged for 6 months using charred white oak segments and a little science to deliver their product faster (www.clevelandwhiskey.com). | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.02.06 | Wpody with a full heavy flavor… not too sweet but definitely sweeter than most. It finishes with an earthy rye but opens with sweet caramel. Amazingly smooth for 50% alcohol. This is such a rich full of flavor bourbon I would buy it again and keep it on hand. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/cleveland/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Cleveland.jpg | Cleveland Whiskey | Cleveland Whiskey | Cleveland, OH | maker of whiskey by massively accelerating the maturiation process | |
| 439 | 80 | 35 | J.R. Ewing | 4-year-old beverage. This is a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey presented in a very cool bottle. | 80 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.02.19 | It reminds me of an episode of cup cake wars; don't worry my kids watch not me :). It tastes of chemicals not of natural flavors. It is chopped just to use another reference. Good mixer potential. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jrewing/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/JREwing.jpg | Southfork Distilling Co., | sourced from an undisclosed Kentucky producer but is bottled by Southfork | Undisclosed | TBD | |
| 443 | 85 | 36 | Jefferson's Ocean Aged at Sea (Voyage #5) | Aged at Sea takes older bourbon barrels and brings it around the world. Stopping in 5 different continents and crossing the equator 4 times, this bourbon truly is a world beater. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.08.15 | Sweet caramel. Nice burn of warm alcohol. Sea salt. Low viscosity. Great story behind its travels. Cool idea and good party discussion. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-ocean-voyage-5/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsOceanVoayage5.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | |
| 445 | 91 | 48 | Old Weller Antique 107 | A wheated bourbon named after William Larue Weller who soe credit being among the first to use wheat instead of rye in straight bourbon. This was originally created by the Stitzel-Weller Distilling Company. | 107 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.08.15 | Scarily drinkable for 107 proof with no ice. At 27 USD it is dangerous | no ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-weller-antique-107/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OldWellerOrg107.jpg | W.L. Weller | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 451 | 83 | 65 | Woodford Reserve Sonoma-Cutrer Finish | Bottle #23,630 of 36,334 total. According to their literature this is a Master's Collection "finished" in French Oak Pinot Noir barrels from California's Sonoma Cutrer Winery. The barrels were used to hold 3 nitages of Burgundian-style Pinot Noir. So we should all find hints of cherry, raspbery and blackberry. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.09.04 | definite notes of spice that dance on your gums. Peppery and fruity and full bodied with a dark rich color. I am not sure I would recommend it at the price. Maybe a good gift for someone who likes woodford reserve or has most other things in life. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/woodford-reserve-sonoma-cutrer-finish/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WoodfordSonomaCutrer.jpg | Woodford Reserve | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 452 | 84 | 65 | Woodford Reserve Sonoma-Cutrer Finish | Bottle #23,630 of 36,334 total. According to their literature this is a Master's Collection "finished" in French Oak Pinot Noir barrels from California's Sonoma Cutrer Winery. The barrels were used to hold 3 nitages of Burgundian-style Pinot Noir. So we should all find hints of cherry, raspbery and blackberry. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.09.04 | wood and fruit but not especially sweet. Still tastes like woodford normal with more oak, fruit and leather. Not a huge fan of normal woodford so surprisingly not a fan of fancy woodford | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/woodford-reserve-sonoma-cutrer-finish/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WoodfordSonomaCutrer.jpg | Woodford Reserve | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 453 | 81 | 32 | Hillrock | Barrel # 13 with Dave Pickerell's Signature | 92 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.09.04 | This has heat so be prepared. The bottle is super cool so it sets you up for a great experience. And it under delivers for me. I felt a film remaining inside my mouth and am not sure that let's me give a fair review. I am left indifferent. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/hillrock/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Hillrock.jpg | Hillrock | A solera aged bourbon. Solera for those of you, like us, that needed to look it up is a "stack of barrels where a small portion of whiskey is removed periodically and new whiskey is added." That is Hillrocks definition. They ensure that no barrell is e | Hillrock Estate Disillery | Ancram, NY | "field to glass" producer |
| 457 | 92 | 61 | Willett Family Estate Single Barrel (14 year; Barrel 2372) | 120 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | -0001.11.30 | wait for a really long time to let the alcohol burn off; very full bodied and strong. I really like the thickness of the caramel; nothing more manly that adding water - which did cut the heat | straight | Willett Family Estate | Willett | Bardstown, KY | |||||
| 458 | 80 | 22 | Elijah Craig Small Batch | 8-12 yr. Bearing the name of Rev. Elijah Craig, credited as the first to age his whiskey in charred oak barrels. Full body for a warm spice and subtle smoke flavor. | 94 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-small-batch/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC12Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 459 | 86 | 22 | Elijah Craig Small Batch | 8-12 yr. Bearing the name of Rev. Elijah Craig, credited as the first to age his whiskey in charred oak barrels. Full body for a warm spice and subtle smoke flavor. | 94 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-small-batch/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC12Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 461 | 89 | 21 | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof | 12 yr. Uncut, straight from the barrel without chill filtering. | 124 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-barrel-proof/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ECBarrelProof.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 462 | 92 | 21 | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof | 12 yr. Uncut, straight from the barrel without chill filtering. | 124 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-barrel-proof/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ECBarrelProof.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 463 | 87 | 21 | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof | 12 yr. Uncut, straight from the barrel without chill filtering. | 124 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2016.07.02 | hot, burn in line with alcohol | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-barrel-proof/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ECBarrelProof.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 474 | 88 | 64 | Woodford Reserve (Batch 498 Bottle 05579) | A well known bourbon from bars to weddings; not to mention many people keep this as their own top shelf house bourbon. We raise our glasses to all our fellow drinkers, but suggest you branch out to more exotic bourbons in the future. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.03.15 | This is the bourbon every old man loves. I think not because it tastes great, but because it brings back memories and still represents bourbon class. This is the classy Makers Mark in my opinion. In fact I would say the flavor is very similar to Makers but a little richer. I have had many good drinks on Woodford, but as for a Woodford Reserve – The Bourbon Guide review….eh not bad. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/18/woodford-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WoodfordReserve.jpg | Woodford Reserve | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 475 | 85 | 64 | Woodford Reserve (Batch 498 Bottle 05579) | A well known bourbon from bars to weddings; not to mention many people keep this as their own top shelf house bourbon. We raise our glasses to all our fellow drinkers, but suggest you branch out to more exotic bourbons in the future. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.03.15 | A standard no frills bourbon. I am not a huge fan nor a huge proponent. I have found myself revising my initial impression of this bourbon which makes me wonder if it is possible to separate its taste with the fun and experiences one typically has when drinking Woodford Reserve. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/18/woodford-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WoodfordReserve.jpg | Woodford Reserve | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 476 | 75 | 64 | Woodford Reserve (Batch 498 Bottle 05579) | A well known bourbon from bars to weddings; not to mention many people keep this as their own top shelf house bourbon. We raise our glasses to all our fellow drinkers, but suggest you branch out to more exotic bourbons in the future. | 90 | 7 | Tony | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/18/woodford-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WoodfordReserve.jpg | Woodford Reserve | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | |||
| 477 | 80 | 64 | Woodford Reserve (Batch 498 Bottle 05579) | A well known bourbon from bars to weddings; not to mention many people keep this as their own top shelf house bourbon. We raise our glasses to all our fellow drinkers, but suggest you branch out to more exotic bourbons in the future. | 90 | 6 | Gill | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/18/woodford-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WoodfordReserve.jpg | Woodford Reserve | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | |||
| 480 | 85 | 25 | Evan Williams 1783 | This bourbon is a steal! It almost made us pass it on as a bottom shelf no name drink, but that would have been a major mistake. This is a real whiskey and should certainly be included in everyone’s collection. Do not let the cheap price tag fool you. My only comment is: why is Makers so much more… and forget some of the other drinks! | 86 | 7 | Tony | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/evans-williams-1783/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EvanWilliams1783.jpg | Evan Williams | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 481 | 95 | 25 | Evan Williams 1783 | This bourbon is a steal! It almost made us pass it on as a bottom shelf no name drink, but that would have been a major mistake. This is a real whiskey and should certainly be included in everyone’s collection. Do not let the cheap price tag fool you. My only comment is: why is Makers so much more… and forget some of the other drinks! | 86 | 6 | Gill | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/evans-williams-1783/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EvanWilliams1783.jpg | Evan Williams | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 482 | 70 | 29 | Four Roses Single Barrel (Barrel GW-5K) | Four Roses has many many variations – we feel they are all in a similar flavor and unfortunately for us it falls more in line with a nice mixer rather than a straight up sipping bourbon. We will likely review many of the Four Roses bands, so stay tuned, we might find one we like. | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 4 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.15 | Not much to say | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/19/four-roses-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/FourRosesSingleBarrel.jpg | Four Roses | Four Roses | Lawrenceburg, KY | ||
| 536 | 92 | 17 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Small Batch | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.04.02 | any nouse guest will enjoy this - smooth 100 proof beverage. Slightly sweet but with a weight to the liquid that holds many flavors while remaining smooth | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsmallbatch/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSmallBatch.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 539 | 82 | 55 | Sazerac Rye | Rye Whiskey dates back to the 1800’s and it was the Sazerac Coffee House on Royal Street (New Orleans) where a drink of Rye Whiskey and Peychaud’s Bitters was first called the “Sazerac”. | 90 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | for a rye really enjoyable | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/sazerac-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SazeracRye.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | |||
| 542 | 85 | 49 | Pendleton 1910 | NOT A bourbon. 100% rye whisky distilled in Canada and is oak-barrel aged a minimum of 12 years. | 80 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2015.10.14 | sweet bottle, smooth like butter, creamy | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Pendleton1910.jpg | Pendleton | established brand in 2003. | Hood River Distillers | Hood River, OR | Oregon’s oldest spirits company, 1934 | |
| 547 | 90 | 31 | Hancock's President's Reserve | A single barrel bourbon whiskey out of Frankfort, Kentucky and this label is owned by Buffalo Trace Distillery, which is a Sazerac company, of course. | 89 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.10.14 | wonderful. A truly pleasant bourbon. Bravo. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/hancocks-presidents-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JohnHancocksReserve.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 549 | 85 | 55 | Sazerac Rye | Rye Whiskey dates back to the 1800’s and it was the Sazerac Coffee House on Royal Street (New Orleans) where a drink of Rye Whiskey and Peychaud’s Bitters was first called the “Sazerac”. | 90 | 4 | Joe | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.10.14 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/sazerac-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SazeracRye.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||||
| 550 | 78 | 26 | Few Rye (Bottle 8) | ‘FEW’ the intials of former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement, Francis E Willard. | 93 | 4 | Joe | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/few-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/FewRye.png | Few | FEW Spirits | Evanston, IL | FEW = Francis E Willard, former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement. | |||
| 552 | 85 | 49 | Pendleton 1910 | NOT A bourbon. 100% rye whisky distilled in Canada and is oak-barrel aged a minimum of 12 years. | 80 | 4 | Joe | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2015.10.14 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Pendleton1910.jpg | Pendleton | established brand in 2003. | Hood River Distillers | Hood River, OR | Oregon’s oldest spirits company, 1934 | ||
| 554 | 75 | 63 | Willett Pot Still Reserve | The first thing to know about this bourbon is that Jason purchased it mostly based on the wicked cool bottle. The bottle alone makes this a must own bourbon for your collection. We think the increased price can easily be justified to your wives or friends as “but I’m going to use the bottle over and over!” Call us shallow or simple, if you will, we scored an incredible bourbon and justified it to ourselves at the very least. The bottle tested in this tasting was 124/272 in batch #9628 . | 94 | 4 | Joe | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/02/15/willetts-pot-still-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Willetts.jpg | Willett Pot Still Reserve | Willett | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 559 | 82 | 58 | Very Old Barton 86 Proof | A Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey aged 4 or 6 years and is bottled in varying strengths | 86 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.10.14 | smooth dessert. Easy drinking. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/very-old-barton-86/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VOB86.jpg | Very Old Barton | Barton 1792 | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 560 | 90 | 49 | Pendleton 1910 | NOT A bourbon. 100% rye whisky distilled in Canada and is oak-barrel aged a minimum of 12 years. | 80 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.10.14 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Pendleton1910.jpg | Pendleton | established brand in 2003. | Hood River Distillers | Hood River, OR | Oregon’s oldest spirits company, 1934 | ||
| 563 | 83 | 36 | Jefferson's Ocean Aged at Sea (Voyage #5) | Aged at Sea takes older bourbon barrels and brings it around the world. Stopping in 5 different continents and crossing the equator 4 times, this bourbon truly is a world beater. | 90 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | some briny; a little burn but a not a deal breaker | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-ocean-voyage-5/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsOceanVoayage5.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | ||
| 564 | 77 | 37 | Jefferson's Presidential 18 yr. | Distilled Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. Distilled from wheat in the fall of 1991 and is batch 12 bottle 1296 having been aged in Stitzel-Weller barrels. Jefferson’s found aged whiskeys to bottle under the Jefferson’s Presidential label of various whiskies ages from 15 to even 30 years. | 94 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.10.14 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-presidential-select-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsPresidential.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | ||
| 571 | 80 | 55 | Sazerac Rye | Rye Whiskey dates back to the 1800’s and it was the Sazerac Coffee House on Royal Street (New Orleans) where a drink of Rye Whiskey and Peychaud’s Bitters was first called the “Sazerac”. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 5 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | sweet for a rye, not a lot of flavor. Hot but drinkable. Thin in flavor but I don't like rye. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/sazerac-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SazeracRye.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | |||
| 573 | 85 | 58 | Very Old Barton 86 Proof | A Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey aged 4 or 6 years and is bottled in varying strengths | 86 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.10.14 | sweet, with less flavor than expected. Starts sweet and ends with aftertaste. Thin but drinkable. A great mixer for the price | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/very-old-barton-86/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VOB86.jpg | Very Old Barton | Barton 1792 | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 574 | 88 | 49 | Pendleton 1910 | NOT A bourbon. 100% rye whisky distilled in Canada and is oak-barrel aged a minimum of 12 years. | 80 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 6 | Full (6) | 2015.10.14 | syrup, cream and smooth are my first 3 thoughts. My next thought is cool bottle. Not a bourbon | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Pendleton1910.jpg | Pendleton | established brand in 2003. | Hood River Distillers | Hood River, OR | Oregon’s oldest spirits company, 1934 | |
| 361 | 85 | 16 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Single Barrel | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.07.21 | Similar body to the small batch – but with less sweetness and bit more harshness. it is more for those that like the spicier leather and hints of caramel and vanilla. | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsinglebarrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSingleBarrel.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 362 | 84 | 16 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Single Barrel | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.07.21 | This is much spicier and less sweet than the small batch. This is very rich and complex and a very nice drink. I prefer the sweeter version of the small batch. I would certainly buy this again. | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsinglebarrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSingleBarrel.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 364 | 92 | 17 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Small Batch | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.07.18 | super complex with sweets, spices, flavor out the wazoo. a truly pleasant drink. I would reach for this over many other Bourbons. Buy this bourbon. It will satisfy sweet and non sweet drinkers. | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsmallbatch/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSmallBatch.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 365 | 80 | 52 | Rock Hill Farms | Single Barrel Bourbon – check out the bottle! It is not weak. This was given to us as a gift from a Kentucky native. It is good having friends from Kentucky. | 100 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 5 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.06.13 | This is a full-bodied bourbon and is not light on the palette. The alcohol level for me warrants adding a little splash of water. Due note that this tasting was only with ice. It is complex and I had trouble wading through the alcohol – but once you do this you will find many flavors to explore. Check it out. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/13/rock-hill-farms/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/RockHillFarms.jpg | Rock Hill Farms | Rock Hill Farms | Frankfort, KY | ||
| 366 | 87 | 52 | Rock Hill Farms | Single Barrel Bourbon – check out the bottle! It is not weak. This was given to us as a gift from a Kentucky native. It is good having friends from Kentucky. | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.06.13 | It is 100 proof people! A very different taste – more fruit and sweetness than wood and earth. Incredibly smooth for a 100 proof bourbon. This bourbon has the coolest of all the bottles; even rivalingWillets. Besides being a very nice drink the is the single best gift bourbon of them all. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/13/rock-hill-farms/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/RockHillFarms.jpg | Rock Hill Farms | Rock Hill Farms | Frankfort, KY | ||
| 368 | 80 | 45 | Old Forester 2012 Birthday | On 8.15.11 it was dumped from barrel no 23 stored in warehouse 11 on rick # 2 – giving us bottle #104. 12 year – Birthday Bourbon 2012 – aged in oak casks. Old Forester puts out a new birthday bourbon each year. Some years are better than others. So as soon as 2013 is bottled and distributed it will be hard to find past years. These are really kind of fun to collect and compare year to year. Unfortunately they are often hard to find and have a much more spicy flavor than we normally enjoy. A few of the other companies put out yearly or experimental bourbons (like Buffalo Trace) and these might be better to collect if you share out pallet for sweet drinks. | 97 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.06.13 | Very smooth with pronounced earth and wood. Not my taste preference but because of the smoothness it is very drinkable. I would not ever buy it again, but the bottle is very cool. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/13/oldforester2012birthday/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OldForresterBirthday.jpg | Old Forester | oldest bourbon continuously on the market – first bottled in 1870 | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | |
| 377 | 86 | 56 | Smooth Ambler Old Scout 6 year | 6 yrs. old 49.5% (101 proof) Batch 8; Bottle Date June 19, 2012; Bottled by JH; West Virginia. This was a brave choice considering the 101 proof of this whiskey. A proper bourbon guide review would best have been done with a splash of water. Brave… that is how we can describe our drinking! | 101 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.04.28 | Fruit follwed by spice. Considering the alcohol content this is quite smooth and nice with a fire blazing in the living room. Recommend to all. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/04/28/smooth-ambler/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmberOldScout-1.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 379 | 85 | 39 | Larceny | Selected to have a taste profile of a 6yr. Kentucky Bourbon having been made with wheat and not rye. | 92 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.04.27 | Good value for money – we hear that this has been selling quite well at the ABC stores. After the first sip and a few seconds I get a numbness between my lips and gums. The second sip is quite drinkable. The price of approx 25 USD can easily be found on sale and thus much cheaper. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/04/27/larceny/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Larceny.jpg | Larceny | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 380 | 88 | 39 | Larceny | Selected to have a taste profile of a 6yr. Kentucky Bourbon having been made with wheat and not rye. | 92 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.04.27 | The nose was thin. Chemical. But not bad. Taste: Sweet and smooth. Very drinkable. Some heat and spice to the flavor at the end. Definitely a wheated" bourbon in the tradition of Pappy Van Winkle." | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/04/27/larceny/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Larceny.jpg | Larceny | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 381 | 81 | 2 | Angel's Envy | Batch 4M Bottle 157 Finished in port wine barrels. 43.3% Fancy smancy! Very cool bottle design and how could port barrel aging be bad? Somewhat controversial as it is not traditional, but we are certainly not elitists so we have no problem with a little experimentation. | 87 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.04.27 | Nice flavor but not my favorite. I would recommend this to those that like a subtle bourbon. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/angels-envy/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/AngelsEnvy.jpg | Angel’s Envy | Angel's Envy | Louisville, KY | ||
| 383 | 79 | 59 | W. L. Weller Special Reserve | The Orginal Wheated Bourbon | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.08.01 | Nice until 1 second after drinking it. Then you get a waft of alcohol rushing your nose but as soon as it appeared it is gone. Then comes the aftertaste – not too bad but not nearly as good as the first flavors you experience. In all an okay bourbon and one that could be a mixer. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/08/01/wellers-special-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WLWellerSpecialReserve.jpg | W.L. Weller | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 384 | 79 | 59 | W. L. Weller Special Reserve | The Orginal Wheated Bourbon | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.08.01 | It is cheap price point is one of positive and its lack of complexity is one of its main negatives. It is thin and flavorless but drinkable. At least it is not too spicy and doesn't have too much of an alcohol burn. Can we all say it together: MIXER! | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/08/01/wellers-special-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WLWellerSpecialReserve.jpg | W.L. Weller | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 389 | 89 | 6 | Black Maple Hill (2013 Original Red Label Wax Top) | Limited Edition – aged in White Oak Casks and Hand Bottled. Red label. | 95 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2013.04.25 | Maybe it is because this bourbon is hard to obtain but even so I really like it. A sweeter bourbon with great color and flavor. I think caramel and candy but with a rounded nature. If it were mine I would reach for it most evenings – good days and bad. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/black-maple-hill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Black-maple-hill-rotated.jpeg | Black Maple Hill | wheated Stizel-Weller but later thought to be sourced from Kentucky Bourbon Distillers | CVI Brands | San Carlos, CA | a non-distiller spirits importer and bottler based |
| 397 | 89 | 25 | Evan Williams 1783 | This bourbon is a steal! It almost made us pass it on as a bottom shelf no name drink, but that would have been a major mistake. This is a real whiskey and should certainly be included in everyone’s collection. Do not let the cheap price tag fool you. My only comment is: why is Makers so much more… and forget some of the other drinks! | 86 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/evans-williams-1783/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EvanWilliams1783.jpg | Evan Williams | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 401 | 80 | 27 | Filibuster Dual cask | 2 distinct oak barrels. Finished in French Oak barrels. The bottle tested was Batch 1, Bottle 3955 and was purchased in Washington DC. This is a 45% alcohol bourbon. This is a novelty type bourbon, and got some great reviews on-line and in magazines. We are lucky to have a bottle, but now that we tried it…we are stuck with a bottle. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.02 | Smooth with a slight alcohol flavor. A lot of wood, too much wood – I am not a lumberjack. A flavor I would never reach for, but good to sample. Having said all of this, there is no more Filibuster to drink. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/02/filibuster/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Filibuster.jpg | Filibuster | MGP of Indiana | Lawrenceburg, IN | Midwest Grain Products of Indiana; owned by Pernod Ricar | |
| 403 | 73 | 42 | Maker's Mark | This is the staple bourbon of our generation (the young winner generation!). The bourbon everyone knows, the bourbon everyone starts drinking and the bourbon the market cannot get enough of. The company was considering, but has since decided not to, a reduction in the alcohol content by 3%. This would have been accomplished by adding water to meet the insane market demand. All bourbon drinkers know this brand and many still like it as a go-to drink. After trying so many Bourbons, many of our friends that are serious bourbon drinkers never buy it again. See our review and you will know why….remember we like sweet bourbon, not earthy spicy bourbon as a norm. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.02 | Somehow you feel compelled to own it- but as soon as you buy another bourbon you will never drink it. You will feel guilty and always suggest this drink for your friends and offer it to others, but never touch it yourself. Spicy and shallow. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/02/makers-mark/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/MakersMark.jpg | Maker's Mark | Maker's Mark | Loretto, KY | ||
| 404 | 71 | 42 | Maker's Mark | This is the staple bourbon of our generation (the young winner generation!). The bourbon everyone knows, the bourbon everyone starts drinking and the bourbon the market cannot get enough of. The company was considering, but has since decided not to, a reduction in the alcohol content by 3%. This would have been accomplished by adding water to meet the insane market demand. All bourbon drinkers know this brand and many still like it as a go-to drink. After trying so many Bourbons, many of our friends that are serious bourbon drinkers never buy it again. See our review and you will know why….remember we like sweet bourbon, not earthy spicy bourbon as a norm. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -6.00 | Full (-6) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.02 | The staple whiskey that made me originally love bourbon (over scotch and other whiskey.) The more bourbon I drink the harder it is to ever go back. This represents my C- drink, passing but not a good grade. This is a friends and family drink only, and the bottle I have now will eventually be given away. You have to really like the earth and spice flavor of bourbon, as well as the tobacco and wood flavor. If people suggest that this is a sweet bourbon, they have clearly not tried some of the other bourbons on the market (or compare it to Jack Daniels or Jim Beam.. yuck!) I would take most anything over this…even wine! | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/02/makers-mark/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/MakersMark.jpg | Maker's Mark | Maker's Mark | Loretto, KY | ||
| 405 | 93 | 63 | Willett Pot Still Reserve | The first thing to know about this bourbon is that Jason purchased it mostly based on the wicked cool bottle. The bottle alone makes this a must own bourbon for your collection. We think the increased price can easily be justified to your wives or friends as “but I’m going to use the bottle over and over!” Call us shallow or simple, if you will, we scored an incredible bourbon and justified it to ourselves at the very least. The bottle tested in this tasting was 124/272 in batch #9628 . | 94 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2013.02.15 | Awesome bottle that can be saved as a decanter. Better with ice to remove some of the alcohol burn and bring out the flavor. Great full taste. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/02/15/willetts-pot-still-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Willetts.jpg | Willett Pot Still Reserve | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 406 | 93 | 63 | Willett Pot Still Reserve | The first thing to know about this bourbon is that Jason purchased it mostly based on the wicked cool bottle. The bottle alone makes this a must own bourbon for your collection. We think the increased price can easily be justified to your wives or friends as “but I’m going to use the bottle over and over!” Call us shallow or simple, if you will, we scored an incredible bourbon and justified it to ourselves at the very least. The bottle tested in this tasting was 124/272 in batch #9628 . | 94 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2013.02.15 | Cool bottle with exceptional whiskey. Absolutely worth the splurge of money and a great addition to any collection. Very smooth considering the high proof and always enjoyable. One of my favorites so far. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/02/15/willetts-pot-still-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Willetts.jpg | Willett Pot Still Reserve | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 411 | 87 | 14 | Bulleit | No specific bottle number. The original Bulleit. A Kentucky straight bourbon made from limestone filtered water and considered a “frontier whiskey” using their words. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.12.11 | This was probably the first fancy bourbon I tried. Yes it was many many years ago. The taste starts off slightly sweet and finishes such that entire experience is neutral on our taste scale. I recommend this to all; if nothing it can be your top shelf mixer. But if you are like me you will have what I shall call bourbon memories – times you spent with friends while having quite a few Bourbons. Well Bulleit has some good memories for me, so here is to making memories. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bulleit-bourbon/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Bulleit.jpg | Bulleit | Four Roses | Lawrenceburg, KY | ||
| 412 | 84 | 14 | Bulleit | No specific bottle number. The original Bulleit. A Kentucky straight bourbon made from limestone filtered water and considered a “frontier whiskey” using their words. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.12.11 | Starts out smooth and sweet, but finishes harsh and spicy. I would say it is a +2 sweet with an 89 rating that slides into a -2 with a 82 rated bourbon. I know this is kinda of schizoid but I would say this is 2 Bourbons for me. This is a large batch production bourbon on par with Makers Mark or Buffalo Trace. This is a good bar drink if few options were available. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bulleit-bourbon/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Bulleit.jpg | Bulleit | Four Roses | Lawrenceburg, KY | ||
| 414 | 80 | 18 | Elijah Craig 12yr | A small batch Kentucky straight bourbon made from limestone filtered water and a special yeast recipe. In their own words “one of the world’s greatest bourbons”. Please read on to see our perspective. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.12.11 | A high proof drink with flavors of pepper, clove and earth but no sweet. This is very smooth and drinkable but not my taste preference. I would recommend this highly to our fans who like the negative side of our taste scale… this will be a mixer for me. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-12yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ElijahCraig12.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 418 | 87 | 11 | Breckenridge | The “World’s Highest Distillery”. This is a 4x winner of Best American Blended (2016, 17, 18, and 2019) from the World Whiskies Awards and Bourbon of the Year in 2011 at the International Wine & Spirits Competition. | 86 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2014.01.13 | Starts out sweet and smooth but has a definite alcohol burn. Finishes at a minus 1 on the sweet scale with spice and leather. This is a very nice drinking whiskey that has some novelty appeal and is worth buying if given the opportunity. A solid B+ bourbon. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/breckenridge/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Breckenridge.jpg | Breckenridge | Breckenridge Distillery | Breckenridge, CO | This is made by the self proclaimed “World’s Highest Distillery” at 9,600 feet using snow melt from the Rocky Mountains. | |
| 421 | 79 | 38 | John B. Stetson | Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. John who lived between 1830-1906 and was a well-known US hatter. Now the company makes bourbon too…a four year old bourbon | 84 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2014.04.30 | I like their hats and they make their bourbon to be consumed in quantity. To so I recommend mixing it rather than drinking it straight. But if you like shots this is a good shot – low in viscosity and flavor. Oh he also started a college in Florida too – can't be good at everything! | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/john-b-stetson | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JohnBStetson.jpg | Stetson | sourced from an undisclosed Kentucky distiller | Undisclosed | TBD | |
| 423 | 74 | 4 | Berkshire | Hand crafted and triple pot distilled in virgin American white oak barrels. They say there are hints of toffee and spice. From Berkshire Mountain Distillers, Sheffield, MA – there first legal distillery since prohibition. | 86 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.05.07 | This was received as a gift. If my initials were BMD it would be even better as they are on the bottle. My first sips went down well but then my head swelled and I had a slight nauseous feeling. So this is a C for me – passing but not that good either. I struggle to even comment on the flavors… | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/berkshire-bourbon/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Berkshire.jpg | Berkshire | Berkshire Mountain Distillers | Sheffield, MA | est.2007 | |
| 427 | 79 | 1 | Ancient Ancient Age 10 Yr | This 6 year old Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey could be called triple A or AAA but that has other connotations. It is the fancier version of Ancient Age. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2014.05.21 | Ok – just ok. This has a twinge of giving you one mean hangover. It also comes with a peppery flavor. Do keep in mind that I drank this pretty cold which makes me think this as a mint jullep could be good. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/ancient-ancient-age/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/AncientAncientAge.jpg | Ancient Age | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 429 | 82 | 31 | Hancock's President's Reserve | A single barrel bourbon whiskey out of Frankfort, Kentucky and this label is owned by Buffalo Trace Distillery, which is a Sazerac company, of course. | 89 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.05.28 | Full bodied with spiciness and tones of wood. After a few sips my mouth still contained these flavors. This has a full body. It starts earthy but slowly calms down leaving the taste of wood behind. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/hancocks-presidents-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JohnHancocksReserve.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 430 | 87 | 31 | Hancock's President's Reserve | A single barrel bourbon whiskey out of Frankfort, Kentucky and this label is owned by Buffalo Trace Distillery, which is a Sazerac company, of course. | 89 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.05.28 | Creamy and heavy very smooth after the initial burn – starts off hot and peppery and finishes off smooth and sweet. I would say it starts as a -2 and finishes as a +2. Not bad not great. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/hancocks-presidents-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JohnHancocksReserve.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 433 | 90 | 23 | Elmer T Lee | A single barrel sour mash Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey. The man himself was George T. Stagg Distillery’s first Master Distiller and started his career their when Col. Albert B. Blanton was their President. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2014.06.11 | This has been in my liquor cabinet for years. Obviously not the same bottle! We like this as it tastes good on the rocks but if you want to dress up a Manhattan or whiskey sour this works really well. Also a great entry bourbon for any of your neophyte friends. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elmer-t-lee/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ElmerTLee.jpg | Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | |||
| 434 | 92 | 23 | Elmer T Lee | A single barrel sour mash Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey. The man himself was George T. Stagg Distillery’s first Master Distiller and started his career their when Col. Albert B. Blanton was their President. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2014.06.11 | Caramel and smooth with an underlying alcohol burn that helps bring the sweetness to the front. A house staple for me that I keep on my shelf at all times. You can drink this straight or you can mix as the price to quality ratio is great. I highly recommend buying a bottle of ETL. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elmer-t-lee/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ElmerTLee.jpg | Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | |||
| 437 | 81 | 51 | Rhetoric | The Orphan Barrel Whiskey Company uses orphaned barrels to bottle bourbon that once drunk are gone for ever. They bottle only in Tullahoma, Tennessee and from what we gather it is also a Diageo product. This particular bottle is a 20-year-old and of course a limited release. (Check them out at www.orphanbarrel.com). | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.02.12 | like sweet and smooth but it unfortunately delivers a nice woody flavor having been in oak for 20 years | w/ ice | ttp://www.thebourbonguide.com/rhetoric/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Rhetoric.jpg | Orphan Barrel | Orphan Barrel Whiskey Distilling Co. | Tullahoma, TN | ||
| 438 | 85 | 51 | Rhetoric | The Orphan Barrel Whiskey Company uses orphaned barrels to bottle bourbon that once drunk are gone for ever. They bottle only in Tullahoma, Tennessee and from what we gather it is also a Diageo product. This particular bottle is a 20-year-old and of course a limited release. (Check them out at www.orphanbarrel.com). | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.02.12 | very Oaky, like it had been aged in the barrel for say like….20 years?? This bourbon is very rich and heavy with an overwhelming wood flavor, it drowns out the sweet caramel. I enjoyed the drink but might not shell out $80+ dollars again for it. | w/ ice | ttp://www.thebourbonguide.com/rhetoric/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/Rhetoric.jpg | Orphan Barrel | Orphan Barrel Whiskey Distilling Co. | Tullahoma, TN | ||
| 441 | 80 | 12 | Buck 8 year old | from caskers: Buck 8 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is matured for a minimum of eight years in new American oak casks under the intense Kentucky sun. As a result of this maturation process, the bourbon has a caramel color, along with an aroma of vanilla, dark fruits, creme brulée and honey. The aroma gives way to notes of cherries, maple syrup, waffle cones and wood spices on the palate, and leads to a finish accented by touches of caramel, charcoal and cocoa. The bourbon earned the Bronze Medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition, and earned a score of 91 points from the Beverage Testing Institute. Pick up a bottle today! | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.08.15 | Not good, not bad. Very burny but sweet. After you drink this you might breath a little fire. Not a rebuy. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/buck-8-yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Buck.jpg | Buck | Frank-Lin Distillers Products | Fairfield, CA | |||
| 442 | 85 | 36 | Jefferson's Ocean Aged at Sea (Voyage #5) | Aged at Sea takes older bourbon barrels and brings it around the world. Stopping in 5 different continents and crossing the equator 4 times, this bourbon truly is a world beater. | 90 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.08.15 | Trace of salt and brine. Unique. Good not great. | no ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-ocean-voyage-5/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsOceanVoayage5.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | |
| 444 | 89 | 36 | Jefferson's Ocean Aged at Sea (Voyage #5) | Aged at Sea takes older bourbon barrels and brings it around the world. Stopping in 5 different continents and crossing the equator 4 times, this bourbon truly is a world beater. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.08.15 | Definitely tast salt and sweet. There is a lot of wood, oak and caramel. Fruity and woody. I liked it… A LOT. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-ocean-voyage-5/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsOceanVoayage5.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | ||
| 449 | 75 | 12 | Buck 8 year old | from caskers: Buck 8 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is matured for a minimum of eight years in new American oak casks under the intense Kentucky sun. As a result of this maturation process, the bourbon has a caramel color, along with an aroma of vanilla, dark fruits, creme brulée and honey. The aroma gives way to notes of cherries, maple syrup, waffle cones and wood spices on the palate, and leads to a finish accented by touches of caramel, charcoal and cocoa. The bourbon earned the Bronze Medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition, and earned a score of 91 points from the Beverage Testing Institute. Pick up a bottle today! | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.08.15 | Let it be said this tasting was late in the evening. Peppery. It gives me that shiver of something not very tasty. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/buck-8-yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Buck.jpg | Buck | Frank-Lin Distillers Products | Fairfield, CA | ||
| 454 | 81 | 32 | Hillrock | Barrel # 13 with Dave Pickerell's Signature | 92 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.09.04 | Best bourbon to come out of NY - which doesn't say much. Thick and tasty but the rye and caramel don't mix as I would want. Not a rebuy - too expensive. Cool bottle. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/hillrock/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Hillrock.jpg | Hillrock | A solera aged bourbon. Solera for those of you, like us, that needed to look it up is a "stack of barrels where a small portion of whiskey is removed periodically and new whiskey is added." That is Hillrocks definition. They ensure that no barrell is e | Hillrock Estate Disillery | Ancram, NY | "field to glass" producer |
| 455 | 82 | 7 | Blade and Bow | They use a Solera System aging process including some of the last Stizle-Weller bourbon produced before it closed in 1992. | 91 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2015.09.04 | Not sure what the key unlocks. I think this would do better on a cold winter day in front of a paper and fireplace as compared to a humid summer night. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/blade-and-bow/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/BladeAndBow.png | Blade And Bow | Stitzel-Weller Distillery | Louisville, KY | owned by Diageo and reopend 2014 | |
| 456 | 83 | 7 | Blade and Bow | They use a Solera System aging process including some of the last Stizle-Weller bourbon produced before it closed in 1992. | 91 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.09.04 | Thin and weak in flavor. Not as good as I hoped for. Seems like it needed to be aged more. Not a re-buy. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/blade-and-bow/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/BladeAndBow.png | Blade And Bow | Stitzel-Weller Distillery | Louisville, KY | owned by Diageo and reopend 2014 | |
| 460 | 84 | 22 | Elijah Craig Small Batch | 8-12 yr. Bearing the name of Rev. Elijah Craig, credited as the first to age his whiskey in charred oak barrels. Full body for a warm spice and subtle smoke flavor. | 94 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-small-batch/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC12Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 468 | 78 | 19 | Elijah Craig 18yr | Bottled from one barrel, no comingling. It should be smooth yet have a complex flavor. | 90 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 1 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC18Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 469 | 77 | 19 | Elijah Craig 18yr | Bottled from one barrel, no comingling. It should be smooth yet have a complex flavor. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | too earthy and woody | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC18Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 472 | 79 | 20 | Elijah Craig 23yr | Aged in the rickhouses lower floors provide a slower aging process. Master Distillers sample barrels and select those to become the Elijah Craig 23-Year-Old Single Barrel. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-23yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC23Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 473 | 93 | 21 | Elijah Craig Barrel Proof | 12 yr. Uncut, straight from the barrel without chill filtering. | 124 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2016.07.02 | w/ H20 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-barrel-proof/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ECBarrelProof.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 483 | 72 | 29 | Four Roses Single Barrel (Barrel GW-5K) | Four Roses has many many variations – we feel they are all in a similar flavor and unfortunately for us it falls more in line with a nice mixer rather than a straight up sipping bourbon. We will likely review many of the Four Roses bands, so stay tuned, we might find one we like. | 100 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.15 | Very posh mixer but not one I would sip neat. Those that like the Four Roses family then I believe this to be a good choice. However, my thoughts are similar to the brief overview above | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/19/four-roses-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/FourRosesSingleBarrel.jpg | Four Roses | Four Roses | Lawrenceburg, KY | ||
| 485 | 70 | 29 | Four Roses Single Barrel (Barrel GW-5K) | Four Roses has many many variations – we feel they are all in a similar flavor and unfortunately for us it falls more in line with a nice mixer rather than a straight up sipping bourbon. We will likely review many of the Four Roses bands, so stay tuned, we might find one we like. | 100 | 6 | Gill | 2 | Neutral | 5 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/19/four-roses-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/FourRosesSingleBarrel.jpg | Four Roses | Four Roses | Lawrenceburg, KY | |||
| 486 | 75 | 53 | Rowan's Creek | This is a great mixer for high end Manhattan’s – it really adds a nice spice and complexity to the drink. This bourbon is for people who like earthy spice in their drink. | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.15 | Sweet but very hot. Very spicy with too much burn. Needs ample water. Not a favorite but drinkable. Seems expensive to be your go to mixer – but some people like a fancy cocktail. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/16/rowans-creek/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/RowansCreek.jpg | Rowan’s Creek | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 487 | 79 | 53 | Rowan's Creek | This is a great mixer for high end Manhattan’s – it really adds a nice spice and complexity to the drink. This bourbon is for people who like earthy spice in their drink. | 100 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.15 | Unless you like spice, I wouldn't recommend this – it is just not my style. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/16/rowans-creek/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/RowansCreek.jpg | Rowan’s Creek | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 488 | 75 | 53 | Rowan's Creek | This is a great mixer for high end Manhattan’s – it really adds a nice spice and complexity to the drink. This bourbon is for people who like earthy spice in their drink. | 100 | 6 | Gill | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.15 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/16/rowans-creek/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/RowansCreek.jpg | Rowan’s Creek | Willett | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 491 | 85 | 34 | Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey (Year 12, Batch 2, Bottle 1218) | is distilled in New York by Tuthilltown using 100% New York corn before being aged in American Oak barrels. The distille ’s website states that this is the first legal pot-distilled whiskey made in New York since prohibition. This was gift for Jason after his wife had a fantastic weekend in New York City. This was a present and is really neat to have in your cabinet for guests to try. We must mention that this is a unique bourbon as it 100% corn and made in Gardinier, New York. | 92 | 7 | Tony | 2 | Neutral | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.03.15 | No further commentary – we are just drinking tonight | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/21/hudson-baby-bourbon-whiskey/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HudsonBaby.jpg | Hudson Baby Bourbon | Tuthilltown Spirits Farm Distillery | Gardiner, NY | NY's first whiskey distillery since prohibition | |
| 535 | 93 | 17 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Small Batch | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.04.02 | super complex with sweet, spices, flavor out the wazoo. A truly pleasant drink. I would reach for this over many other bourbons. Buy this bourbon. It will satisfy sweet and non sweet drinkers. | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsmallbatch/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSmallBatch.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 537 | 87 | 16 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Single Barrel | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.04.02 | much spicier and less sweet than the small batch. This is very rich and complex and a very nice drink. I prefer the sweeter cousin of the "small batch". I would certainly buy this again. | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsinglebarrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSingleBarrel.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 538 | 85 | 16 | Colonel E. H. Taylor Single Barrel | Bottled in Bond. This is the classic bourbon whiskey bottle, with the tapered neck and tall classy body. These bottles are sometimes referred to as lady legs because of the taper and style. The label is very classy and this bottle just looks good in your liqueur cabinet. You might have to buy it just to look that cool. Just saying… | 100 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.04.02 | Similar body to the small batch - but with less sweetness more for those that like a spicier leather with hints of caramel and vanilla | w/ Ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/coloneltaylorsinglebarrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/TaylorSingleBarrel.jpg | E.H. Taylor Jr. Collection | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 541 | 77 | 58 | Very Old Barton 86 Proof | A Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey aged 4 or 6 years and is bottled in varying strengths | 86 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | good bargain - hospital aftertaste | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/very-old-barton-86/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VOB86.jpg | Very Old Barton | Barton 1792 | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 545 | 76 | 63 | Willett Pot Still Reserve | The first thing to know about this bourbon is that Jason purchased it mostly based on the wicked cool bottle. The bottle alone makes this a must own bourbon for your collection. We think the increased price can easily be justified to your wives or friends as “but I’m going to use the bottle over and over!” Call us shallow or simple, if you will, we scored an incredible bourbon and justified it to ourselves at the very least. The bottle tested in this tasting was 124/272 in batch #9628 . | 94 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.10.14 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/02/15/willetts-pot-still-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Willetts.jpg | Willett Pot Still Reserve | Willett | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 546 | 76 | 29 | Four Roses Single Barrel (Barrel GW-5K) | Four Roses has many many variations – we feel they are all in a similar flavor and unfortunately for us it falls more in line with a nice mixer rather than a straight up sipping bourbon. We will likely review many of the Four Roses bands, so stay tuned, we might find one we like. | 100 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.10.14 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/19/four-roses-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/FourRosesSingleBarrel.jpg | Four Roses | Four Roses | Lawrenceburg, KY | |||
| 548 | 75 | 37 | Jefferson's Presidential 18 yr. | Distilled Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. Distilled from wheat in the fall of 1991 and is batch 12 bottle 1296 having been aged in Stitzel-Weller barrels. Jefferson’s found aged whiskeys to bottle under the Jefferson’s Presidential label of various whiskies ages from 15 to even 30 years. | 94 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-presidential-select-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsPresidential.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | ||
| 551 | 88 | 58 | Very Old Barton 86 Proof | A Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey aged 4 or 6 years and is bottled in varying strengths | 86 | 4 | Joe | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2015.10.14 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/very-old-barton-86/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VOB86.jpg | Very Old Barton | Barton 1792 | Bardstown, KY | ||||
| 555 | 85 | 31 | Hancock's President's Reserve | A single barrel bourbon whiskey out of Frankfort, Kentucky and this label is owned by Buffalo Trace Distillery, which is a Sazerac company, of course. | 89 | 4 | Joe | 2 | Neutral | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.10.14 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/hancocks-presidents-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JohnHancocksReserve.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | |||
| 556 | 78 | 37 | Jefferson's Presidential 18 yr. | Distilled Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. Distilled from wheat in the fall of 1991 and is batch 12 bottle 1296 having been aged in Stitzel-Weller barrels. Jefferson’s found aged whiskeys to bottle under the Jefferson’s Presidential label of various whiskies ages from 15 to even 30 years. | 94 | 4 | Joe | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-presidential-select-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsPresidential.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | ||
| 557 | 75 | 55 | Sazerac Rye | Rye Whiskey dates back to the 1800’s and it was the Sazerac Coffee House on Royal Street (New Orleans) where a drink of Rye Whiskey and Peychaud’s Bitters was first called the “Sazerac”. | 90 | 5 | Sam | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | Biker body odor | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/sazerac-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SazeracRye.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | |||
| 562 | 75 | 63 | Willett Pot Still Reserve | The first thing to know about this bourbon is that Jason purchased it mostly based on the wicked cool bottle. The bottle alone makes this a must own bourbon for your collection. We think the increased price can easily be justified to your wives or friends as “but I’m going to use the bottle over and over!” Call us shallow or simple, if you will, we scored an incredible bourbon and justified it to ourselves at the very least. The bottle tested in this tasting was 124/272 in batch #9628 . | 94 | 5 | Sam | 2 | Neutral | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.10.14 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/02/15/willetts-pot-still-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Willetts.jpg | Willett Pot Still Reserve | Willett | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 565 | 80 | 55 | Sazerac Rye | Rye Whiskey dates back to the 1800’s and it was the Sazerac Coffee House on Royal Street (New Orleans) where a drink of Rye Whiskey and Peychaud’s Bitters was first called the “Sazerac”. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2015.10.14 | it feels like a climber wearing crampons running around your tongue; flat - no complexity - I struggle to find anything and thus I wouldn't reach for it | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/sazerac-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SazeracRye.jpg | Sazerac | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 568 | 86 | 49 | Pendleton 1910 | NOT A bourbon. 100% rye whisky distilled in Canada and is oak-barrel aged a minimum of 12 years. | 80 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 7 | Strong (7) | 2015.10.14 | I am a sucker for a cool bottle; high viscosity - full bodied and smooth; Oh Canada Go Canada | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Pendleton1910.jpg | Pendleton | established brand in 2003. | Hood River Distillers | Hood River, OR | Oregon’s oldest spirits company, 1934 | |
| 367 | 72 | 45 | Old Forester 2012 Birthday | On 8.15.11 it was dumped from barrel no 23 stored in warehouse 11 on rick # 2 – giving us bottle #104. 12 year – Birthday Bourbon 2012 – aged in oak casks. Old Forester puts out a new birthday bourbon each year. Some years are better than others. So as soon as 2013 is bottled and distributed it will be hard to find past years. These are really kind of fun to collect and compare year to year. Unfortunately they are often hard to find and have a much more spicy flavor than we normally enjoy. A few of the other companies put out yearly or experimental bourbons (like Buffalo Trace) and these might be better to collect if you share out pallet for sweet drinks. | 97 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.06.13 | A little like placing your nose in a wood box. The drink starts off smooth and timid as compared to its finish which is not good. It is definitely not my birthday! Great for a mixer only as it will add spice and heat – alcohol style. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/06/13/oldforester2012birthday/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OldForresterBirthday.jpg | Old Forester | oldest bourbon continuously on the market – first bottled in 1870 | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | |
| 370 | 80 | 8 | Blanton's Bottle 104 | Each bottle has a distinctive cork with a letter imbedded into the picture of the horse. The idea is to collect all of the letters. This bottle was the letter L – We have are not even close to collecting of the corks to spell B L A N T O N S. Honestly, we are big fan's of cool bottles and gimmicks, but this is just a little too much. Bourbon was dumped on 2011.08.15 from barrel no 23 stored in warehouse 11 on rick # 2 – giving us bottle #104. | 93 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.06.13 | Fire burn start – sweet finish. Not very spicy but definitely not very sweet. Vanilla and close finish and it is not a great after taste. It is a very cool bottle with a collectors cork – thus a great gift bourbon. Not one I will buy again for myself. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/blantons/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Blantons.jpg | Blanton's Single Barrel | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 382 | 80 | 2 | Angel's Envy | Batch 4M Bottle 157 Finished in port wine barrels. 43.3% Fancy smancy! Very cool bottle design and how could port barrel aging be bad? Somewhat controversial as it is not traditional, but we are certainly not elitists so we have no problem with a little experimentation. | 87 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.04.27 | Not a rebuy but worth a try. A different fruity taste and quite smooth but not as good as I hoped. Nose: Fruit and sweet caramel. Subtle chemical smell. Taste: Corn, sweet, then fire. Not a burn. No spice or leather, but sweet then fire. Some fruit in there. Notes: Not bad, but has a unique fruit taste that makes it different. Subtle then strong. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/angels-envy/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/AngelsEnvy.jpg | Angel’s Envy | Angel's Envy | Louisville, KY | ||
| 387 | 75 | 10 | Bowman Brothers Small Batch | Read the back of the bottle for a good story. To note, they don't produce their own whiskey, they do, however, use their copper still to re-distill it before 6 or so 7 years of on-site aging. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.04.27 | Spicy no sweet – I like sweet – I know I have said it before. Probably nice in a whisky sour or some such cocktail. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bowman-brothers/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/BowmanBrothers.jpg | Bowman Brothers | Bowman Brothers | Fredricksburg, VA | ||
| 388 | 73 | 10 | Bowman Brothers Small Batch | Read the back of the bottle for a good story. To note, they don't produce their own whiskey, they do, however, use their copper still to re-distill it before 6 or so 7 years of on-site aging. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -6.00 | Full (-6) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.04.27 | Way too spicy for my taste. Very full of earth, leather, spice, clove. Never would I reach for this over a sweeter or smoother bourbon. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bowman-brothers/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/BowmanBrothers.jpg | Bowman Brothers | Bowman Brothers | Fredricksburg, VA | ||
| 407 | 82 | 13 | Buffalo Trace | Our first review of a bourbon will be Buffalo Trace Kentucky bourbon. This is a great bourbon to start with. It is very reasonably priced, easy to find and has a very mild taste that many people enjoy. We consider this a bourbon to rate other bourbons against. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.01.23 | A solid everyday drinking bourbon. A good value for the money, but not an elite drink. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/buffalo-trace/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/BuffaloTrace.jpg | Buffalo Trace | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 408 | 84 | 13 | Buffalo Trace | Our first review of a bourbon will be Buffalo Trace Kentucky bourbon. This is a great bourbon to start with. It is very reasonably priced, easy to find and has a very mild taste that many people enjoy. We consider this a bourbon to rate other bourbons against. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2013.01.23 | Great value for the money. A bourbon you must always keep in your cabinet for everyday drinking and sharing with friends. This drink starts smooth and sweet, but finishes very rough and shallow compared to more expensive bourbons. The end is far worse than the start. Still a nice drink………….. ADDENDUM: After trying so many more bourbons, I would keep my review and ratings the same, but say this is not a MUST HAVE drink. I would order this over Makers or Woodford, but not over Evan WIlliams 1783 or many of the elite bourbons. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/buffalo-trace/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/BuffaloTrace.jpg | Buffalo Trace | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 415 | 79 | 40 | Leopold Bros | Bottle Number 84. A small batch whiskey (NOT A BOURBON) pot stilled using open fermented mash. It is from Colorado. | 86 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.01.14 | I drink this while thinking of the impending Beam Inc. sale to Suntory Holdings, a Japanese company. I guess big business is always big business – it is never just about being American owned and made. I digress… this drink is light colored which for a split second might make you think of a kids apple juice, but then you get a strong smell of alcohol and you know it is nothing of the sort. I think it smells of peat and earth and resembles a scotch. If you are curious, I would first have a taste at a restaurant or from a friend rather than buying a bottle | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/leopold-bros/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Leopolds.jpg | Leopold | Leopold Bros. | Denver, CO | a family-owned and operated distillery | |
| 416 | 65 | 40 | Leopold Bros | Bottle Number 84. A small batch whiskey (NOT A BOURBON) pot stilled using open fermented mash. It is from Colorado. | 86 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -6.00 | Full (-6) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.01.14 | Hold you nose and shoot it down. This whiskey is not bourbon but tastes like chewing on a spicy oak red hot. If you like smokey woody alcohol I've got a bottle I can't get rid off. But in all fairness it should not be judged against sweet delicious bourbons. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/leopold-bros/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Leopolds.jpg | Leopold | Leopold Bros. | Denver, CO | a family-owned and operated distillery | |
| 422 | 80 | 38 | John B. Stetson | Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. John who lived between 1830-1906 and was a well-known US hatter. Now the company makes bourbon too…a four year old bourbon | 84 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2014.04.30 | This is a very thin bourbon. There is not a lot of deep flavors. The flavors I do get are earth, spice and a little bit of vanilla. I would consider this much more of a mixing bourbon than a sipping bourbon. For the price, I can think of far better drinks. Stick to hats Stetson. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/john-b-stetson | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JohnBStetson.jpg | Stetson | sourced from an undisclosed Kentucky distiller | Undisclosed | TBD | |
| 424 | 70 | 4 | Berkshire | Hand crafted and triple pot distilled in virgin American white oak barrels. They say there are hints of toffee and spice. From Berkshire Mountain Distillers, Sheffield, MA – there first legal distillery since prohibition. | 86 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.05.07 | Yikes! Not a pleasant taste to be found in this bourbon. Massachusetts needs to stick to beer and crabs. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/berkshire-bourbon/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Berkshire.jpg | Berkshire | Berkshire Mountain Distillers | Sheffield, MA | est.2007 | |
| 431 | 85 | 37 | Jefferson's Presidential 18 yr. | Distilled Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. Distilled from wheat in the fall of 1991 and is batch 12 bottle 1296 having been aged in Stitzel-Weller barrels. Jefferson’s found aged whiskeys to bottle under the Jefferson’s Presidential label of various whiskies ages from 15 to even 30 years. | 94 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.06.04 | This causes your gums to tingle as you come to terms with the pepper while sipping this full bodied bourbon. A good special occasion especially for those that like a more wooden earth flavored drink with some strong alcohol after taste. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-presidential-select-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsPresidential.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | |
| 432 | 87 | 37 | Jefferson's Presidential 18 yr. | Distilled Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. Distilled from wheat in the fall of 1991 and is batch 12 bottle 1296 having been aged in Stitzel-Weller barrels. Jefferson’s found aged whiskeys to bottle under the Jefferson’s Presidential label of various whiskies ages from 15 to even 30 years. | 94 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2014.06.04 | Not worth the price but a definite keeper. If you get a chance to try it – do so, but let someone else pay for it. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-presidential-select-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsPresidential.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | |
| 440 | 75 | 35 | J.R. Ewing | 4-year-old beverage. This is a Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey presented in a very cool bottle. | 80 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.02.19 | There is a funny taste to this very thin bourbon, not sweet and not earthy but thin. It has a very cool bottle but you can definitely do better for the price. The smell and the taste have a very plastic nature to it , like it was aged in Tupperware not oak. Patrick Ewing was great (go NY Knicks) but JR Ewing needs to stick with oil and not bourbon. | on rocks | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jrewing/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/JREwing.jpg | Southfork Distilling Co., | sourced from an undisclosed Kentucky producer but is bottled by Southfork | Undisclosed | TBD | |
| 446 | 84 | 48 | Old Weller Antique 107 | A wheated bourbon named after William Larue Weller who soe credit being among the first to use wheat instead of rye in straight bourbon. This was originally created by the Stitzel-Weller Distilling Company. | 107 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2015.08.15 | Has a vet cabinet smell whatever that is. The alcohol burns off in your esophagus but after the first sip you get a much more smooth experience. If you have had a bad day and need a quick shot…maybe. Otherwise sit and add some water. | w/ 1 ice cube | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-weller-antique-107/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OldWellerOrg107.jpg | W.L. Weller | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 447 | 82 | 48 | Old Weller Antique 107 | A wheated bourbon named after William Larue Weller who soe credit being among the first to use wheat instead of rye in straight bourbon. This was originally created by the Stitzel-Weller Distilling Company. | 107 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.08.15 | Heat! A lot of heat, but a smooth sweet heat. This is a very drinkable bourbon for a great price. Bewareyea lightweights this is a high proof hot bourbon. | no ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-weller-antique-107/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OldWellerOrg107.jpg | W.L. Weller | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 448 | 82 | 12 | Buck 8 year old | from caskers: Buck 8 Year Old Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey is matured for a minimum of eight years in new American oak casks under the intense Kentucky sun. As a result of this maturation process, the bourbon has a caramel color, along with an aroma of vanilla, dark fruits, creme brulée and honey. The aroma gives way to notes of cherries, maple syrup, waffle cones and wood spices on the palate, and leads to a finish accented by touches of caramel, charcoal and cocoa. The bourbon earned the Bronze Medal at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition, and earned a score of 91 points from the Beverage Testing Institute. Pick up a bottle today! | 90 | 3 | Chad | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.08.15 | Too much leather. Tastes rusty. Drinkable but not preferable | no ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/buck-8-yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Buck.jpg | Buck | Frank-Lin Distillers Products | Fairfield, CA | ||
| 464 | 85 | 18 | Elijah Craig 12yr | A small batch Kentucky straight bourbon made from limestone filtered water and a special yeast recipe. In their own words “one of the world’s greatest bourbons”. Please read on to see our perspective. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-12yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ElijahCraig12.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 465 | 87 | 18 | Elijah Craig 12yr | A small batch Kentucky straight bourbon made from limestone filtered water and a special yeast recipe. In their own words “one of the world’s greatest bourbons”. Please read on to see our perspective. | 90 | 3 | Chad | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-12yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ElijahCraig12.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 466 | 80 | 18 | Elijah Craig 12yr | A small batch Kentucky straight bourbon made from limestone filtered water and a special yeast recipe. In their own words “one of the world’s greatest bourbons”. Please read on to see our perspective. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | smokey | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-12yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/ElijahCraig12.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 467 | 76 | 19 | Elijah Craig 18yr | Bottled from one barrel, no comingling. It should be smooth yet have a complex flavor. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC18Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 470 | 72 | 20 | Elijah Craig 23yr | Aged in the rickhouses lower floors provide a slower aging process. Master Distillers sample barrels and select those to become the Elijah Craig 23-Year-Old Single Barrel. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-23yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC23Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 471 | 80 | 20 | Elijah Craig 23yr | Aged in the rickhouses lower floors provide a slower aging process. Master Distillers sample barrels and select those to become the Elijah Craig 23-Year-Old Single Barrel. | 90 | 3 | Chad | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2016.07.02 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-23yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC23Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 484 | 59 | 29 | Four Roses Single Barrel (Barrel GW-5K) | Four Roses has many many variations – we feel they are all in a similar flavor and unfortunately for us it falls more in line with a nice mixer rather than a straight up sipping bourbon. We will likely review many of the Four Roses bands, so stay tuned, we might find one we like. | 100 | 7 | Tony | 3 | Unpleasant | 5 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2013.03.15 | Not much to say. I would probably not even call this a mixer stock for me. I find the taste way to spicy and earthy to be enjoyable. I would rather have a gin and tonic over this..blasphemy! All of Kentucky will be after me now, | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/19/four-roses-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/FourRosesSingleBarrel.jpg | Four Roses | Four Roses | Lawrenceburg, KY | ||
| 489 | 80 | 34 | Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey (Year 12, Batch 2, Bottle 1218) | is distilled in New York by Tuthilltown using 100% New York corn before being aged in American Oak barrels. The distille ’s website states that this is the first legal pot-distilled whiskey made in New York since prohibition. This was gift for Jason after his wife had a fantastic weekend in New York City. This was a present and is really neat to have in your cabinet for guests to try. We must mention that this is a unique bourbon as it 100% corn and made in Gardinier, New York. | 92 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2013.03.15 | Come on New York; you can do better! As a native New Yorker, I was really hoping to love this bourbon. Fail. Not sweet and not particularly pleasant on the palate. I would not reach for this and the price makes it hard to buy. However, it remains a great novelty bourbon especially when considering the bottle. Not worth the money is the key thing to remember – yet a great gift idea. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/21/hudson-baby-bourbon-whiskey/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HudsonBaby.jpg | Hudson Baby Bourbon | Tuthilltown Spirits Farm Distillery | Gardiner, NY | NY's first whiskey distillery since prohibition | |
| 490 | 80 | 34 | Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey (Year 12, Batch 2, Bottle 1218) | is distilled in New York by Tuthilltown using 100% New York corn before being aged in American Oak barrels. The distille ’s website states that this is the first legal pot-distilled whiskey made in New York since prohibition. This was gift for Jason after his wife had a fantastic weekend in New York City. This was a present and is really neat to have in your cabinet for guests to try. We must mention that this is a unique bourbon as it 100% corn and made in Gardinier, New York. | 92 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.03.15 | A really unique flavor one that you should really try – quite expensive at 375ml. Not one I will reach for but if someone is looking for different this is your choice. I have no plans to move to NY and this does not help. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/21/hudson-baby-bourbon-whiskey/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HudsonBaby.jpg | Hudson Baby Bourbon | Tuthilltown Spirits Farm Distillery | Gardiner, NY | NY's first whiskey distillery since prohibition | |
| 492 | 80 | 34 | Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey (Year 12, Batch 2, Bottle 1218) | is distilled in New York by Tuthilltown using 100% New York corn before being aged in American Oak barrels. The distille ’s website states that this is the first legal pot-distilled whiskey made in New York since prohibition. This was gift for Jason after his wife had a fantastic weekend in New York City. This was a present and is really neat to have in your cabinet for guests to try. We must mention that this is a unique bourbon as it 100% corn and made in Gardinier, New York. | 92 | 6 | Gill | 3 | Unpleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.03.15 | No further commentary – we are just drinking tonight | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/03/21/hudson-baby-bourbon-whiskey/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HudsonBaby.jpg | Hudson Baby Bourbon | Tuthilltown Spirits Farm Distillery | Gardiner, NY | NY's first whiskey distillery since prohibition | |
| 540 | 65 | 26 | Few Rye (Bottle 8) | ‘FEW’ the intials of former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement, Francis E Willard. | 93 | 3 | Chad | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | straight from a saddle bag or pharmacy shelf in 1850 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/few-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/FewRye.png | Few | FEW Spirits | Evanston, IL | FEW = Francis E Willard, former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement. | ||
| 558 | 72 | 26 | Few Rye (Bottle 8) | ‘FEW’ the intials of former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement, Francis E Willard. | 93 | 5 | Sam | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | good flavor overall. Slight aftertaste | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/few-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/FewRye.png | Few | FEW Spirits | Evanston, IL | FEW = Francis E Willard, former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement. | ||
| 566 | 78 | 26 | Few Rye (Bottle 8) | ‘FEW’ the intials of former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement, Francis E Willard. | 93 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | ethanol - did I stand in a room that just got cleaned; pepper shaker; not my thing; but if I were a Rye fan the score should change | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/few-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/FewRye.png | Few | FEW Spirits | Evanston, IL | FEW = Francis E Willard, former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement. | ||
| 567 | 83 | 58 | Very Old Barton 86 Proof | A Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey aged 4 or 6 years and is bottled in varying strengths | 86 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | the taste does linger and disipates to where you either need to drink more or something else; low viscosity | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/very-old-barton-86/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/VOB86.jpg | Very Old Barton | Barton 1792 | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 570 | 70 | 37 | Jefferson's Presidential 18 yr. | Distilled Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey aged a minimum of four years in charred oak casks. Distilled from wheat in the fall of 1991 and is batch 12 bottle 1296 having been aged in Stitzel-Weller barrels. Jefferson’s found aged whiskeys to bottle under the Jefferson’s Presidential label of various whiskies ages from 15 to even 30 years. | 94 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | watch out for the alcohol about 2 seconds in; so much heat - I can't get past the alcohol - it is just awful | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/jeffersons-presidential-select-18yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/JeffersonsPresidential.jpg | Jefferson's | Founded in 1997, Jefferson’s is the brainchild of Trey Zoeller and his father Chet, a famed bourbon historian. They were continuing a family tradition that goes back to Trey’s 8th generation grandmother who was arrested in 1799 for the “production and sal | Jefferson's | Crestwood, KY | |
| 572 | 81 | 26 | Few Rye (Bottle 8) | ‘FEW’ the intials of former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement, Francis E Willard. | 93 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | very strong, maybe too strong. Pepper, leather, earth. Not sweet | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/few-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/FewRye.png | Few | FEW Spirits | Evanston, IL | FEW = Francis E Willard, former President of the Women’s Christian Temperance Movement. | ||
| 577 | 85 | 46 | Old Grand-Dad | bottled in bond; high rye mash bill | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.12 | mixture of rye and sweet caramel; super thin with no after taste; incredible mixer; killer with ginger ale | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-grand-dad-bonded-ogd/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OGD-bonded-rotated.jpeg | Old Grand-Dad | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 578 | 83 | 46 | Old Grand-Dad | bottled in bond; high rye mash bill | 100 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.12 | ryey not earthy; glug glug glug - or you could simply drink a lot of it | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-grand-dad-bonded-ogd/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OGD-bonded-rotated.jpeg | Old Grand-Dad | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 579 | 80 | 46 | Old Grand-Dad | bottled in bond; high rye mash bill | 100 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.12 | great value for the money; first sip has some heartburn; second - jury is still out | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-grand-dad-bonded-ogd/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/OGD-bonded-rotated.jpeg | Old Grand-Dad | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 584 | 85 | 43 | Michter's 10 Single Barrel | 2016 Barrel #809 | 94 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | it has a nice personality bourbon - nice looking bottle | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/michters-10/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Micters-10-rotated.jpeg | Michter's | family owned bourbon | Michter's | Louisville, KY | |
| 587 | 88 | 47 | Old Rip Van Winkle (2019) | Van Winkle bottle this close to barrel proof but they do add a little Kentucky limestone well-water in the hope to make it smooth. | 107 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.12 | a touch of soap lingers on the palate; | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-rip-van-winkle/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/old-rip-10-rotated.jpeg | Van Winkle | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 588 | 84 | 47 | Old Rip Van Winkle (2019) | Van Winkle bottle this close to barrel proof but they do add a little Kentucky limestone well-water in the hope to make it smooth. | 107 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.02.12 | a dark rich bourbon as compared to other 10 year; I really liked the weight of the liquid; secondary pricing is outrageous and not worth it | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-rip-van-winkle/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/old-rip-10-rotated.jpeg | Van Winkle | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 589 | 65 | 44 | Old Fitzgerald 101 | 1989 - 10 year; Japanese export | 101 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | I don't like stitzel weller at all; medicinal with a shot of cleaner to boot | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-fitz-101/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Old-Fitz-101-rotated.jpeg | Old Fitzgerald | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 590 | 71 | 44 | Old Fitzgerald 101 | 1989 - 10 year; Japanese export | 101 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | way better smell than taste; no complexity; thin; medicinal; formaldehyde | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-fitz-101/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Old-Fitz-101-rotated.jpeg | Old Fitzgerald | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 591 | 72 | 44 | Old Fitzgerald 101 | 1989 - 10 year; Japanese export | 101 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | smells like a famous person's library; there is no roundness but a clear clinical flavor; if this were a wine it is past its prime | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-fitz-101/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Old-Fitz-101-rotated.jpeg | Old Fitzgerald | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 592 | 90 | 60 | Walker's Deluxe Bourbon (1976 - 8 year) | One of the top products of Hiram Walker & Sons distillery and debuted in the 1960 | 80 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.02.12 | I feel like I am in mad men; it is like butter; on a hot summer day I would drink this whole bottle | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/walkers-deluxe-1976/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/walkers-delux-8yr-rotated.jpeg | Walker's | Hiram Walker & Sons distiller | Peoria, Illinois | ||
| 593 | 85 | 60 | Walker's Deluxe Bourbon (1976 - 8 year) | One of the top products of Hiram Walker & Sons distillery and debuted in the 1960 | 80 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.12 | I feel like I am in 1970s chicago; smells like carrot cake; compared to smell the taste lets it down; but I could drink this all day while playing badminton; like a melted butter bomb but not complexity and richness | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/walkers-deluxe-1976/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/walkers-delux-8yr-rotated.jpeg | Walker's | Hiram Walker & Sons distiller | Peoria, Illinois | ||
| 594 | 86 | 60 | Walker's Deluxe Bourbon (1976 - 8 year) | One of the top products of Hiram Walker & Sons distillery and debuted in the 1960 | 80 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.02.12 | super cool decanter; a very nice smell and smooth | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/walkers-deluxe-1976/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/walkers-delux-8yr-rotated.jpeg | Walker's | Hiram Walker & Sons distiller | Peoria, Illinois | ||
| 604 | 85 | 24 | Big Bottom Barlow Trail | A blended American whiskey with little details: a blend of three well-aged whiskeys with no neutral spirits. So you can figure out what it isn't at least! | 91 | 4 | Joe | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/big-bottom-barlow-trail/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/BigBottomBarlowSmallBatch.jpg | Barlow | Big Bottom Distillery | Hillsboro, OR | Started as a bottler in 2010, and has started to distill spirits. | |||
| 620 | 87 | 24 | Big Bottom Barlow Trail | A blended American whiskey with little details: a blend of three well-aged whiskeys with no neutral spirits. So you can figure out what it isn't at least! | 91 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2015.10.14 | Vanilla and smooth | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/big-bottom-barlow-trail/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/BigBottomBarlowSmallBatch.jpg | Barlow | Big Bottom Distillery | Hillsboro, OR | Started as a bottler in 2010, and has started to distill spirits. | ||
| 649 | 95 | 62 | Willett Family Estate Single Barrel (14 year; Barrel 3261; 142/153) | An un-chill?ltered, barrel proof, straight Bourbon whose label exists only for their Private Barrel Selection program, and is one of a kind. | 119 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.02.12 | this is my jam; | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/willet-14-yr-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/willett-14-3261-rotated.jpeg | Willett Family Estate | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 650 | 96 | 62 | Willett Family Estate Single Barrel (14 year; Barrel 3261; 142/153) | An un-chill?ltered, barrel proof, straight Bourbon whose label exists only for their Private Barrel Selection program, and is one of a kind. | 119 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.02.12 | this is the sh*t; this is what bourbon should taste like. It is hot and it burns like embers not flame | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/willet-14-yr-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/willett-14-3261-rotated.jpeg | Willett Family Estate | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 651 | 94 | 62 | Willett Family Estate Single Barrel (14 year; Barrel 3261; 142/153) | An un-chill?ltered, barrel proof, straight Bourbon whose label exists only for their Private Barrel Selection program, and is one of a kind. | 119 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2020.02.12 | amazing bourbon - if you have friends that let you have some NEVER pass it up; it is so delectable; | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/willet-14-yr-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/willett-14-3261-rotated.jpeg | Willett Family Estate | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 656 | 88 | 66 | Wild Turkey Tradition 14yr | Only 30,000 bottles were ever produced of this limited edition bourbon, with 14,000 allocated to the US market. Aged in new heavily charred American oak barrels placed in the "center cut" of the distillery's oldest warehouse, it was bottled at 101 proof. | 101 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.02.21 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WildTurkeyTradition14.jpg | Wild Turkey | Wild Turkey Distilling Co | Lawrenceburg, KY | a division of Campari Group | ||
| 657 | 88 | 66 | Wild Turkey Tradition 14yr | Only 30,000 bottles were ever produced of this limited edition bourbon, with 14,000 allocated to the US market. Aged in new heavily charred American oak barrels placed in the "center cut" of the distillery's oldest warehouse, it was bottled at 101 proof. | 101 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.21 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WildTurkeyTradition14.jpg | Wild Turkey | Wild Turkey Distilling Co | Lawrenceburg, KY | a division of Campari Group | ||
| 658 | 83 | 70 | Henry Mckenna Single Barrel Bourbon | Bonded 10 year Barreled Oct 26, 2001 Barrel # 868 | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2020.03.07 | overhyped overrated - I don't love it | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/henry-mckenna/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HenryMcKenna.jpg | Henry McKenna | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 659 | 83 | 70 | Henry Mckenna Single Barrel Bourbon | Bonded 10 year Barreled Oct 26, 2001 Barrel # 868 | 100 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.03.07 | it is average but drinkable | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/henry-mckenna/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HenryMcKenna.jpg | Henry McKenna | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 660 | 82 | 70 | Henry Mckenna Single Barrel Bourbon | Bonded 10 year Barreled Oct 26, 2001 Barrel # 868 | 100 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.03.07 | nice bourbon for the price - nothing special | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/henry-mckenna/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HenryMcKenna.jpg | Henry McKenna | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 661 | 80 | 70 | Henry Mckenna Single Barrel Bourbon | Bonded 10 year Barreled Oct 26, 2001 Barrel # 868 | 100 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.03.07 | drinkable but there is a lingering flavor that was not delicious - it makes you take another sip to cover up this aftertaste | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/henry-mckenna/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/HenryMcKenna.jpg | Henry McKenna | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 662 | 91 | 5 | William Heavenhill Single Barrel | Barrel #13 (of 30) Barreled Feb 6, 2003 and bottled April 20, 2017; 5th Edition offered from Rickhouse U floor 3 | 115 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2020.03.07 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/william-heavenhill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WilliamHeavenhill.jpg | Heaven Hill | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 664 | 90 | 5 | William Heavenhill Single Barrel | Barrel #13 (of 30) Barreled Feb 6, 2003 and bottled April 20, 2017; 5th Edition offered from Rickhouse U floor 3 | 115 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2020.03.07 | high earth flavor but no leather | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/william-heavenhill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WilliamHeavenhill.jpg | Heaven Hill | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 670 | 93 | 75 | Smooth Ambler 10 year | at least 10 years old, Batch 47 and Bottled by Sarah on March 2, 2016 | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.03.07 | delicious sweet bourbon | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-ten/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmblerTen.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 671 | 92 | 75 | Smooth Ambler 10 year | at least 10 years old, Batch 47 and Bottled by Sarah on March 2, 2016 | 100 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.03.07 | I'd buy it everyday - unfortunately you can't | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-ten/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmblerTen.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 672 | 92 | 75 | Smooth Ambler 10 year | at least 10 years old, Batch 47 and Bottled by Sarah on March 2, 2016 | 100 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 1 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.03.07 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-ten/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmblerTen.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | |||
| 673 | 90 | 75 | Smooth Ambler 10 year | at least 10 years old, Batch 47 and Bottled by Sarah on March 2, 2016 | 100 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2020.03.07 | They found good bourbon, ensured it was aged at least 10 years and blended it. But not this is discontinued. If you have it - enjoy this easy drinking bourbon with good weight and flavor. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-ten/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmblerTen.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 674 | 88 | 76 | Smooth Ambler Old Scout No Age | MGP as its distilled in Indiana; Batch No 40 Bottled by Sarah | 99 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 3 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2020.03.07 | musky but sweet - buy it if you see it | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-old-scout/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmberOldScout.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 675 | 88 | 76 | Smooth Ambler Old Scout No Age | MGP as its distilled in Indiana; Batch No 40 Bottled by Sarah | 99 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.03.07 | same flavor profile as the 10 year but not as good | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-old-scout/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmberOldScout.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 676 | 85 | 76 | Smooth Ambler Old Scout No Age | MGP as its distilled in Indiana; Batch No 40 Bottled by Sarah | 99 | 3 | Chad | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2020.03.07 | nice pleasant sweet bourbon; it's a drinker | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-old-scout/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmberOldScout.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 677 | 84 | 76 | Smooth Ambler Old Scout No Age | MGP as its distilled in Indiana; Batch No 40 Bottled by Sarah | 99 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.03.07 | not as rich as the 10 year but still really nice; a little thinner not as full bodied | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/smooth-ambler-old-scout/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/SmoothAmberOldScout.jpg | Smooth Ambler | Smooth Ambler | Maxwelton, WV | ||
| 679 | 79 | 50 | Rebel Reserve | Bottle number 28285; Batch number 1709 | 91 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2013.08.01 | Now I did let my ice melt quite a lot. So this was more like a drowning Rebel than a dry one – which made the drinking smoother. I did notice some spiciness on my gums after a relatively dessert like taste. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/08/01/rebel-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/RebelReserve.jpg | Rebel | Lux Row Distillers | Bardstown, Ky | ||
| 684 | 75 | 68 | High West American Prairie | Batch no. 19E08. At least 2 years old of sourced whiskeys and High West pledges to donate 10% of after tax profits to the American Prairie Reserve. | 92 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 5 | Adequate (5) | 2020.08.01 | Pure alcohol. No Joy. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/high-west-american-prairie/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/HighWestPrairie.Front_.jpg | High West American Prairie | High West Distillery | Wanship, Utah | Just 25 mins from Park City, Utah | |
| 688 | 85 | 77 | 0 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.08.01 | Very flavorful. Great value for the money, if you can find it. Just misses the mark for an A bourbon. | neat | Henry McKenna | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||||||
| 689 | 85 | 77 | 0 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.08.01 | Chewed up peppercorns. | neat | Henry McKenna | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||||||
| 690 | 92 | 77 | 0 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.08.01 | I could drink this every night and I do drink this every night. Mix it. Spicey and full of flavor. | neat | Henry McKenna | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||||||
| 691 | 86 | 78 | Baker's Single Barrel | Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey. Barreled 01-2011. Aged 8 years 6 months. | 107 | 1 | Jason | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.08.01 | Hard to find but nice | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bakers-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Bakers.Front_.jpg | Baker's Single Barrel | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 692 | 84 | 78 | Baker's Single Barrel | Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey. Barreled 01-2011. Aged 8 years 6 months. | 107 | 2 | Tripp | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.08.01 | Hot, sweet and drinkable | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bakers-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Bakers.Front_.jpg | Baker's Single Barrel | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 693 | 80 | 78 | Baker's Single Barrel | Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey. Barreled 01-2011. Aged 8 years 6 months. | 107 | 5 | Sam | 1 | Pleasant | 2 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.08.01 | I like it. It is not that bad but I would not seek it out. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/bakers-single-barrel/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Bakers.Front_.jpg | Baker's Single Barrel | Jim Beam | Clermont, KY | ||
| 580 | 74 | 30 | George Dickel Bottled in Bond | George Dickel (Bottled in Bond, Distilling season Fall 2005, 14 year, rated Whiskey Guide 2019 #1 ) | 100 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -6.00 | Full (-6) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | why is this the whiskey of the year? Use it like a rye in an old fashioned or manhattan - no sweet all earth | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/george-dickel-bottled-in-bond/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Dickel-rotated.jpeg | George Dickel | George Dickel | TULLAHOMA, TN | Not a Bourbon - Tennessee Whiskey | |
| 582 | 78 | 30 | George Dickel Bottled in Bond | George Dickel (Bottled in Bond, Distilling season Fall 2005, 14 year, rated Whiskey Guide 2019 #1 ) | 100 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | it leaves an odd aftertaste and is a great mixer because of the earthiness of this whisky; | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/george-dickel-bottled-in-bond/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Dickel-rotated.jpeg | George Dickel | George Dickel | TULLAHOMA, TN | Not a Bourbon - Tennessee Whiskey | |
| 585 | 82 | 43 | Michter's 10 Single Barrel | 2016 Barrel #809 | 94 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | it left my mouth very dry but nicely warming | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/michters-10/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Micters-10-rotated.jpeg | Michter's | family owned bourbon | Michter's | Louisville, KY | |
| 586 | 90 | 47 | Old Rip Van Winkle (2019) | Van Winkle bottle this close to barrel proof but they do add a little Kentucky limestone well-water in the hope to make it smooth. | 107 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.02.12 | way better than I thought; chalky; deep flavor; sweet; not worth the secondary price - at 69 buy all day long | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/old-rip-van-winkle/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/old-rip-10-rotated.jpeg | Van Winkle | Buffalo Trace | Frankfurt, KY | ||
| 595 | 80 | 24 | Big Bottom Barlow Trail | A blended American whiskey with little details: a blend of three well-aged whiskeys with no neutral spirits. So you can figure out what it isn't at least! | 91 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | ok | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/big-bottom-barlow-trail/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/BigBottomBarlowSmallBatch.jpg | Barlow | Big Bottom Distillery | Hillsboro, OR | Started as a bottler in 2010, and has started to distill spirits. | ||
| 612 | 80 | 24 | Big Bottom Barlow Trail | A blended American whiskey with little details: a blend of three well-aged whiskeys with no neutral spirits. So you can figure out what it isn't at least! | 91 | 5 | Sam | 2 | Neutral | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | a little harsh - too much burn. | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/big-bottom-barlow-trail/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/BigBottomBarlowSmallBatch.jpg | Barlow | Big Bottom Distillery | Hillsboro, OR | Started as a bottler in 2010, and has started to distill spirits. | ||
| 652 | 82 | 20 | Elijah Craig 23yr | Aged in the rickhouses lower floors provide a slower aging process. Master Distillers sample barrels and select those to become the Elijah Craig 23-Year-Old Single Barrel. | 90 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 1 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2020.02.21 | Smells like the underside of a rotten log; Tastes better than it smells but… | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-23yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC23Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 655 | 84 | 66 | Wild Turkey Tradition 14yr | Only 30,000 bottles were ever produced of this limited edition bourbon, with 14,000 allocated to the US market. Aged in new heavily charred American oak barrels placed in the "center cut" of the distillery's oldest warehouse, it was bottled at 101 proof. | 101 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 1 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.21 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/pendleton-1910/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WildTurkeyTradition14.jpg | Wild Turkey | Wild Turkey Distilling Co | Lawrenceburg, KY | a division of Campari Group | ||
| 663 | 87 | 5 | William Heavenhill Single Barrel | Barrel #13 (of 30) Barreled Feb 6, 2003 and bottled April 20, 2017; 5th Edition offered from Rickhouse U floor 3 | 115 | 5 | Sam | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.03.07 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/william-heavenhill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WilliamHeavenhill.jpg | Heaven Hill | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 665 | 85 | 5 | William Heavenhill Single Barrel | Barrel #13 (of 30) Barreled Feb 6, 2003 and bottled April 20, 2017; 5th Edition offered from Rickhouse U floor 3 | 115 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 1 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.03.07 | A complex bourbon that has high alcohol but runs smooth. Many a flavor can be discovered. I would definitely recommend this to anyone. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/william-heavenhill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/WilliamHeavenhill.jpg | Heaven Hill | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 666 | 89 | 74 | Knob Creek Rye Cask Strength 2019 | Batch 2; Barreled 2010 Warehouse A; winner of the 2018 best rye award | 127 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -6.00 | Full (-6) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2020.03.07 | not my normal flavor profile; it is different I liked it | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/knob-creek-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/KnobCreekRye.jpg | Knob Creek | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 668 | 79 | 74 | Knob Creek Rye Cask Strength 2019 | Batch 2; Barreled 2010 Warehouse A; winner of the 2018 best rye award | 127 | 3 | Chad | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2020.03.07 | Young high test | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/knob-creek-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/KnobCreekRye.jpg | Knob Creek | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 669 | 77 | 74 | Knob Creek Rye Cask Strength 2019 | Batch 2; Barreled 2010 Warehouse A; winner of the 2018 best rye award | 127 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 4 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.03.07 | Rye - it is a Rye! Very warming. I did not try adding a little water but it would bring the flavors out and hide a little of the heater. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/knob-creek-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/KnobCreekRye.jpg | Knob Creek | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 680 | 80 | 50 | Rebel Reserve | Bottle number 28285; Batch number 1709 | 91 | 2 | Tripp | 2 | Neutral | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 1 | Barely (1) | 2013.08.01 | Nutty, fruity, weak! Definitely not a favorite. I would say this is very mixable due to its weakness and the fact that I need to get rid of the rest of the bottle. Thankfully this is a cheap bourbon and I don't feel jipped. Not a rebuy. | w/ ice | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/08/01/rebel-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/RebelReserve.jpg | Rebel | Lux Row Distillers | Bardstown, Ky | ||
| 682 | 75 | 67 | Legent | Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey made by Two legends. Fred Noe and Shinji Fukuyo. Partially finished in wine and sherry casks. | 94 | 5 | Sam | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.08.01 | There is nothing stand out ish. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/legent/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Legent.Front_.jpg | Legent | Legent Distilling Co. | Clermont, KY | ||
| 683 | 81 | 67 | Legent | Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey made by Two legends. Fred Noe and Shinji Fukuyo. Partially finished in wine and sherry casks. | 94 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.08.01 | Drinkable. Probably tough as your first drink but this was after a couple manhattans. It was a gift too. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/legent/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Legent.Front_.jpg | Legent | Legent Distilling Co. | Clermont, KY | ||
| 685 | 82 | 68 | High West American Prairie | Batch no. 19E08. At least 2 years old of sourced whiskeys and High West pledges to donate 10% of after tax profits to the American Prairie Reserve. | 92 | 5 | Sam | 2 | Neutral | 2 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.08.01 | It is an interesting Utah bourbon. One of the better High West options. Utah bed Kentucky it is disappointing | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/high-west-american-prairie/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/HighWestPrairie.Front_.jpg | High West American Prairie | High West Distillery | Wanship, Utah | Just 25 mins from Park City, Utah | |
| 686 | 76 | 68 | High West American Prairie | Batch no. 19E08. At least 2 years old of sourced whiskeys and High West pledges to donate 10% of after tax profits to the American Prairie Reserve. | 92 | 1 | Jason | 2 | Neutral | 3 | -1.00 | Barely (-1) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.08.01 | Spicy. Alcohol smell. Ok. Cool bottle. Great place to eat. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/high-west-american-prairie/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/HighWestPrairie.Front_.jpg | High West American Prairie | High West Distillery | Wanship, Utah | Just 25 mins from Park City, Utah | |
| 576 | 73 | 63 | Willett Pot Still Reserve | The first thing to know about this bourbon is that Jason purchased it mostly based on the wicked cool bottle. The bottle alone makes this a must own bourbon for your collection. We think the increased price can easily be justified to your wives or friends as “but I’m going to use the bottle over and over!” Call us shallow or simple, if you will, we scored an incredible bourbon and justified it to ourselves at the very least. The bottle tested in this tasting was 124/272 in batch #9628 . | 94 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | high octane; alcohol burn; racing fuel | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/2013/02/15/willetts-pot-still-reserve/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Willetts.jpg | Willett Pot Still Reserve | Willett | Bardstown, KY | ||
| 581 | 75 | 30 | George Dickel Bottled in Bond | George Dickel (Bottled in Bond, Distilling season Fall 2005, 14 year, rated Whiskey Guide 2019 #1 ) | 100 | 3 | Chad | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -5.00 | Adequate (-5) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | I smell sour; this is the flat earth bourbon; | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/george-dickel-bottled-in-bond/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Dickel-rotated.jpeg | George Dickel | George Dickel | TULLAHOMA, TN | Not a Bourbon - Tennessee Whiskey | |
| 583 | 83 | 43 | Michter's 10 Single Barrel | 2016 Barrel #809 | 94 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.12 | no where near the money - dry - no complexity - touch of sweet with no earthy | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/michters-10/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Micters-10-rotated.jpeg | Michter's | family owned bourbon | Michter's | Louisville, KY | |
| 626 | 80 | 24 | Big Bottom Barlow Trail | A blended American whiskey with little details: a blend of three well-aged whiskeys with no neutral spirits. So you can figure out what it isn't at least! | 91 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | 0.00 | Neutral (0) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2015.10.14 | Thin with a clinical taste. Sweet but not a lot of deep flavor. Not a favorite | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/big-bottom-barlow-trail/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/BigBottomBarlowSmallBatch.jpg | Barlow | Big Bottom Distillery | Hillsboro, OR | Started as a bottler in 2010, and has started to distill spirits. | ||
| 646 | 95 | 6 | Black Maple Hill (2013 Original Red Label Wax Top) | Limited Edition – aged in White Oak Casks and Hand Bottled. Red label. | 95 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 4 | Noticeable (4) | 2020.02.12 | that is a good bourbon; what else could you ask for in bourbon | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/black-maple-hill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Black-maple-hill-rotated.jpeg | Black Maple Hill | wheated Stizel-Weller but later thought to be sourced from Kentucky Bourbon Distillers | CVI Brands | San Carlos, CA | a non-distiller spirits importer and bottler based |
| 647 | 92 | 6 | Black Maple Hill (2013 Original Red Label Wax Top) | Limited Edition – aged in White Oak Casks and Hand Bottled. Red label. | 95 | 3 | Chad | 3 | Unpleasant | 1 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.12 | tastes so much better than it tastes; a long melt into your throat and that is awesome; "earth candy" | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/black-maple-hill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Black-maple-hill-rotated.jpeg | Black Maple Hill | wheated Stizel-Weller but later thought to be sourced from Kentucky Bourbon Distillers | CVI Brands | San Carlos, CA | a non-distiller spirits importer and bottler based |
| 648 | 91 | 6 | Black Maple Hill (2013 Original Red Label Wax Top) | Limited Edition – aged in White Oak Casks and Hand Bottled. Red label. | 95 | 1 | Jason | 3 | Unpleasant | 2 | -3.00 | Somewhat (-3) | 3 | Somewhat (3) | 2020.02.12 | complex; it simply takes me back 8 years when we could drink this and the memories it brings back | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/black-maple-hill/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/Black-maple-hill-rotated.jpeg | Black Maple Hill | wheated Stizel-Weller but later thought to be sourced from Kentucky Bourbon Distillers | CVI Brands | San Carlos, CA | a non-distiller spirits importer and bottler based |
| 653 | 80 | 20 | Elijah Craig 23yr | Aged in the rickhouses lower floors provide a slower aging process. Master Distillers sample barrels and select those to become the Elijah Craig 23-Year-Old Single Barrel. | 90 | 3 | Chad | 3 | Unpleasant | 1 | -6.00 | Full (-6) | 0 | Neutral (0) | 2020.02.21 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-23yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC23Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 654 | 83 | 20 | Elijah Craig 23yr | Aged in the rickhouses lower floors provide a slower aging process. Master Distillers sample barrels and select those to become the Elijah Craig 23-Year-Old Single Barrel. | 90 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | -2.00 | Faint (-2) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.02.21 | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/elijah-craig-23yr/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/EC23Front.jpg | Elijah Craig Collection | Heaven Hill | Bardstown, KY | |||
| 667 | 72 | 74 | Knob Creek Rye Cask Strength 2019 | Batch 2; Barreled 2010 Warehouse A; winner of the 2018 best rye award | 127 | 5 | Sam | 3 | Unpleasant | 4 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.03.07 | too hot to enjoy it | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/knob-creek-rye/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/KnobCreekRye.jpg | Knob Creek | Brown Forman | Louisville, KY | ||
| 681 | 80 | 67 | Legent | Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey made by Two legends. Fred Noe and Shinji Fukuyo. Partially finished in wine and sherry casks. | 94 | 2 | Tripp | 3 | Unpleasant | 3 | -4.00 | Noticeable (-4) | 2 | Faint (2) | 2020.08.01 | A bog standard offering.Boring. | neat | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/legent/ | https://www.thebourbonguide.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Legent.Front_.jpg | Legent | Legent Distilling Co. | Clermont, KY |
Great site!! But then again I wrote it. Just getting the ball rolling!
Nice site and some good reviews! It seems Tripp and I share a preference for cigars and bourbon. I have considered several of the reviewed brands before and tried a few others. Now I have a few new brands to look out for and I know some not to waste my time with.
james, give me your feedback after you have tried a few. See if our reviews were accurate.